Chapter 1
Sunday Supper Society
The farmhouse smells like rosemary and roasting chicken.
I stand at the oven, checking the bird for the third time in ten minutes. The skin is browning, the potatoes are crisping alongside it, and I'm trying to remember everything Vonnie, who owns the Friendly Corner Café, told me over the phone this morning.
'Just let it cook, hon. Stop opening the oven.' I recall her instructions.
I nod like she can see me. Then I'd open the oven twice more anyway.
Axel watches, from his spot by the back door, nose twitching. Axel’s a red, shaggy, telepathic, opinionated Standard Poodle that I inherited from my Uncle Bud, along with this farm.
Smells good.
"It's for the Queenagers, not you."
Share.
"No."
He sighs like I've personally wronged him, then settles his chin on his paws with the long-suffering patience of a dog who knows the humans will cave eventually.
From the top of the refrigerator, Rowan surveys the scene with the calm arrogance of a queen reviewing her kingdom. She's huge for a cat, an orange Maine Coon with a plume of a tail and amber eyes that see more than they should. Martha rescued her last fall and lent her to me after I mentioned I had a mouse problem that Axel refused to help me with. Rowan solved that problem in three days and then refused to leave.
She yawns, showing sharp white teeth.
Chicken's dry.
"It's not dry."
Will be.
I ignore her.
I hear both of them in my head. Another thing I inherited from my Uncle Bud.
It's the second Sunday in January, which means the Sunday Supper Society is meeting here tonight. We rotate houses, and this week it's my turn to host. I don't cook - never have, probably never will - but Vonnie walked me through the chicken prep step by step, and somehow I've managed not to burn the house down.
Yet.
Outside, snow piles against the fence line. The kind of cold that makes your face hurt just looking at it through the window. We’ve been snowed in for weeks - not literally, but close enough for this Florida transplant that the world has shrunk to the size of Grandview and its surrounding farms.
Thanksgiving bled into Christmas, Christmas into New Year's, and now here we are in mid-January with nothing to do but watch the thermometer drop and wonder if spring is a myth.
Cabin fever doesn't begin to cover it.
The Queenagers and I closed the Richmond Baby case on November 17th, a decades-old disappearance we finally resolved. The plan was to take a week or two off, maybe enjoy the holidays without thinking about Uncle Bud's files or cold cases or any of it. Just eat too much, drink more coffee than is good for us, a little wine for variety, and pretend we are normal people doing normal things.
That was almost two months ago.
I've known the Queenagers less than a year - I moved to Grandview last summer after inheriting Uncle Bud's farmhouse - but they folded me into their group like I'd always been there. They've known each other for years. I'm still the new one, but they don't make me feel like it.
The timer dings. I pull the chicken from the oven and set it on the counter to rest. The skin crackles, golden and almost perfect. Axel's head lifts immediately.
For me?
"Not even close."
Rude.
Rowan stretches, her back arching.
I'm setting out plates when headlights sweep across the living room window. The maroon Oldsmobile - Vonnie's late husband's car, the one she still drives like it's the most reliable thing in her world. She's early, which means she'll walk in, take one look at my kitchen setup, and start rearranging things with the confidence of someone who's been feeding people for decades.
I love her for it.
The door opens without a knock - we're past that now. Vonnie breezes in carrying a casserole dish in one hand and a basket that smells like fresh bread in the other. Her long braid swings over one shoulder as she kicks the door shut with her boot.
"Hon, look at you! You didn't burn anything."
"You walked me through it step by step."
She laughs. "I did. And you actually listened." She sets the casserole on the table and peers at the chicken. "Let it rest another five minutes. Don't cut into it yet."
"I wasn't going to."
"Yes, you were."
She's right, but I don't admit it.
More headlights. Martha's ruby red Ford Explorer pulls into the driveway, followed by Demi's sleek silver sedan. Linny's paint-splattered hatchback appears last, all a little worse for wear from winter road salt and grime.
They pile in together, arms full of food and wine and the kind of easy laughter that only comes from women who've known each other forever. The cold follows them inside, sharp and biting, but the warmth of the kitchen pushes it back.
Linny, the artist with paint on everything, kisses my cheek. She smells faintly of lavender and something herbal I can't quite place. "Smells wonderful, Willie."
Demi, our tech-and-numbers wizard, sets down a bottle of wine that probably costs more than my heating bill. The label is French and elegant. "I brought the good stuff."
"You always bring the good stuff," I say.
"Why settle for less?"
Linny drops a tote bag on the chair, her scarf trailing glitter that I'll be finding in my floorboards for weeks. "I made cookies. They're a little lopsided."
"They're perfect," Vonnie says, already inspecting them with the discerning eye of someone who's been running cafés and diners for decades. She picks one up, examines it, takes a bite. "Maybe a little overbaked."
"Vonnie." Linny laughs.
"What? You asked."
"I didn't ask."
Martha, a cat magnet and psychologist with a profiler’s eye, intervenes with the calm of a woman who's spent years managing egos far more fragile than Linny and Vonnie's. "They're lovely. And the shape gives them character."
Linny beams. “Thanks Martha.”
Rowan drops from the refrigerator and winds between Martha's legs. Martha reaches down automatically, scratching behind the cat's ears.
"How's our girl settling in?" Martha asks.
"She's claimed the entire house," I say. "Axel's learned to live with it."
Bossy, Axel mutters from the floor.
Competent, Rowan corrects, purring.
We settle in around the table. Food gets passed, wine gets poured, and for a while we just eat and talk about nothing important. Vonnie's testing a new soup for the café menu - butternut squash with sage. Linny's working on a mural for the library. Martha's fostering three more cats, all orange, all with attitude problems.
"Why are they always orange?" I ask.
Martha shrugs. "The universe has a sense of humor."
Demi cuts into her chicken with surgical precision. "I've been reorganizing my investment portfolio. It's deeply unsatisfying."
"That's because numbers don't fight back," Vonnie says.
"Exactly." Demi takes a sip of wine. "I miss the Richmond case. At least that had stakes."
The table goes quiet for a beat. The Richmond Baby case had plenty of stakes. Too many, maybe. But Demi's not wrong - there's something about working a case that makes you feel like you're doing something that matters.
Vonnie leans back in her chair. "So are we doing this or not?"
"Doing what?" Linny asks, though her tone suggests she already knows.
"Bud's files." Demi looks at me. "We said we'd take a break. It's been two months. I'm going stir-crazy."
Martha nods. "I've reorganized my office twice. The cats are concerned."
Linny laughs. "I've painted three snow scenes. The snow and the light that hits it can be beautiful but three? I’m running low on white paint and I’m really starting to hate snow."
I glance under the table. Axel's sprawled on his side, belly full and content, one paw twitching in some dream I'll never fully understand.
Bored. Need case.
"Even Axel's bored," I say.
Vonnie grins. "Then let's pick a file."
We clear the dishes and take our coffee into the living room. I grab Uncle Bud’s files from his little office off the kitchen. It used to be a mudroom before Uncle Bud converted it - just big enough for a desk, a filing cabinet, and a chair that creaks when you sit in it. The filing cabinet holds what's left of Bud's cases. We'd gone through his files months ago and narrowed them down to six that seemed worth pursuing. Solved one. Five left.
I place the files in a neat row on the coffee table, each labeled in Bud's careful handwriting.
Demi reaches past me, fingers trailing over the tabs. She's careful, deliberate, the way she always is when she's handling something that matters. She pulls out a file labeled Community Center Financial Irregularities - 2020 and opens it.
Her expression shifts almost immediately.
"This one," she says.
Martha leans closer. "What is it?"
"Contractor fraud. Maybe." Demi flips through Bud's notes, her eyes scanning the pages with the speed of someone who reads financial statements the way most people read novels. "George Holt ran the Community Center renovation back in 2020. Bud flagged the invoices - thought Holt was padding them."
"Was he?" Vonnie asks.
Demi flips through Bud's notes, studying the handwritten columns and invoice copies. "I can see what Bud was thinking. The pattern looks suspicious - similar markup percentages across different line items, consistently inflated compared to what you'd expect for materials and labor. But his work is all on paper. I'll need to input everything into my software to confirm the numbers actually prove fraud versus just aggressive pricing."
"How long would that take?" I ask.
"Depends on how much data there is. It’ll probably take a few days to input it and run the analysis. But honestly?" She taps the file. "I don't think that's the real question anymore."
Martha leans forward. "What do you mean?"
"Holt died two years ago. Heart attack." Demi pulls out a page near the back - Bud's handwriting tight and questioning: Who approved these invoices? Director? Board member? Volunteer coordinator? Too systematic for contractor alone. Need to talk to Center.
She flips to the next page. "After Holt died, looks like Bud approached the Director. From his notes it doesn’t look like he accused anyone directly, just said the invoices looked questionable and maybe they should review their approval processes going forward. The Director agreed, said they'd look into tightening things up."
"And then?" Vonnie asks.
Demi's voice softens. "Then I guess that's when Bud got sick. There’s no further note to show he ever followed up to see if they actually made changes. That's probably why the file’s still open."
The room goes still.
Linny breaks the silence. "So we're just finishing what he started. Checking if they actually fixed the problem."
"Right," Demi says. "The real question now isn't 'did Holt commit fraud - it's 'does the Community Center have better financial controls in place, or did they just let it slide after Bud stopped asking? Although I will still double check Bud’s work before I approach the Director."
Martha nods slowly. "You want to see if they followed through."
"Exactly. If they tightened up their approval process like they told Bud they would, then we can close his file knowing the vulnerability was addressed. But if they didn't-" Demi pauses. "Then the same sloppy oversight that let Holt get away with it could still be there."
"Meaning someone else could be taking advantage," I say.
"Possibly. Or maybe they fixed it and I'll confirm everything's fine. Either way, I think it’s worthwhile to find out if Bud’s concerns were taken seriously."
I look at the file spread across the coffee table. Not a mystery, just unfinished business.
"What do you need?" I ask.
"Access to the Community Center's current financial records. I'll approach the Director, explain I'm wrapping up old files for Willie's uncle, and ask to verify they addressed Bud's concerns from two years ago. It's reasonable - I'm not accusing anyone, just confirming the issue was resolved."
"You think he'll cooperate?" Vonnie asks.
"I think he'll be relieved someone's finally closing an old loose end. And while I'm there reviewing their current practices, I can confirm whether they actually tightened things up or just ignored Bud after he stopped asking."
"And if they did tighten up?" I ask.
"Then we close the file. Holt was a lone operator who got lucky with lax oversight. Case solved, move on."
"And if they didn't?"
Demi meets my eyes. "Then we keep digging."
She looks around at all of us. "Either way, this should be straightforward. Just record keeping, comparing old practices to current ones. Nothing like the Richmond Baby case - that one got complicated fast."
Axel lifts his head.
Famous last words.
I ignore him. So does Rowan, though her tail twitches.
Vonnie raises her coffee cup. "To Bud's files. And to not freezing to death before spring."
We clink our mugs. The furnace hums. Outside, the wind picks up, blowing snow down off the roof making it look like it’s snowing harder than it is.
We talk logistics for another half hour. Demi will spend the next few days preparing her analysis, pulling together everything Bud had and cross-referencing it with her own software. Then she'll approach the Director, get access and dig into the source documents. The rest of us will stay on standby - ready to help if she needs us, ready to step in if the case turns into something more than financial record-keeping.
It feels good to have a plan again. Purpose. Something to do besides watch snow fall and wonder if winter will ever end.
By the time everyone leaves, it's late. The only sound in the house is the furnace kicking in too often and the hum of the refrigerator in the kitchen.
I stand at the sink, washing the last of the pans, watching snow fall outside the window. Fat flakes drifting down in the glow of the back porch light.
Axel pads over and sits beside me, his warm bulk pressing against my leg. Rowan perches on the counter, tail wrapped around her paws.
You think it's just record keeping? Axel asks.
"Demi said so."
That’s her plan, Axel says. Plans change.
"What's that supposed to mean?"
He yawns, showing all his teeth.
It never stays that simple.
We hope you are enjoying the book so far. To continue reading...
Copyright © 2026 All Rights Reserved