Chapter 1
Sunday Supper Society
Martha's house smells like roast beef and gravy. I'm setting out the last of the silverware when Vonnie arrives, arms full of covered dishes. Axel, my opinionated red, shaggy, Standard Poodle, trots over to investigate.
Apple pie.
"How do you know?" I ask.
Axel sits. I can smell it. Also, she always brings apple pie.
Vonnie sets the dishes on the counter. "What did Axel say?”
“He told me you brought apple pie.” I laugh.
“He knows me too well and I know how to make sure he’s happy to see me,” Vonnie replies as she reaches down to scratch Axel's ears.
I'm happy to see the pie.
Demi arrives next with her leather portfolio tucked under one arm and a casserole dish balanced in the other. She's dressed like she just came from a board meeting, which knowing Demi, she probably did.
"Green bean casserole," she announces. "With the crispy onions."
Linny bursts through the door last, a whirlwind of yarn and color. Her tote bag looks like it might explode at any moment. She's balancing a basket of rolls that look homemade.
"I didn't make these. I stopped at the bakery and they put them into a basket for me so I could say I made them," she admits with a giggle, setting the basket on the table. "But I did bring my camera because tonight feels official."
"First official meeting," Martha says, carrying out the first of many platters. "October twenty-seventh. I'll remember this date."
We settle around Martha's dining table. Five place settings. Five women, five friends, one family.
The Queenagers, as the town affectionately refers to us. I'm still getting used to it.
We pass the food around. Linny's bakery rolls are perfect, soft and buttery. Demi's casserole is crispy on top, creamy underneath. Martha's roast can be cut with a fork.
The conversation flows easily. Vonnie tells a story about a customer at the café who tried to order a pierogi smoothie. Linny shows us photos from the last art class she taught at the library. Demi mentions a stock that doubled overnight.
Axel parks himself under the table, strategically positioned between my chair and Vonnie's.
Maximum snack potential.
With the plates mostly empty and the conversation winding down, Demi reaches for her portfolio.
"So," she says, pausing slightly. "Bud's files."
The mood shifts. Not heavy, but focused.
Demi opens the portfolio and pulls out six folders. Not a mountain of paper, just six cases that deserve attention.
"I went through all twelve," she says. "These six still have witnesses, evidence trails. The others are so cold they’re frozen solid ."
Martha clears space on the sideboard, moving aside a collection of origami cranes she said she'd folded during a particularly long video call with her husband overseas.
Demi spreads the folders out in a neat row. "Missing baby from 1998," she says, tapping the first folder. "Business thefts from the early 2000s. Property dispute from fifteen years ago. Missing person from 2018. Financial irregularities at the community center in 2020. Unexplained accident on Highway 83 in 2022."
"Six cases Bud wanted solved," I say quietly.
"Six chances to finish what he started," Martha adds.
For a moment, nobody moves. We're standing around Martha's dining table, looking at six folders that represent years of Bud's unfinished work. Six cases still waiting for answers.
"Are we really doing this?" Martha asks, her voice gentle but serious. "Taking on Bud's cold cases?"
"I think we are," Vonnie says.
"We wouldn't be here if we weren't meant to," Linny adds.
Demi nods. "Bud believed these cases deserved answers. I think we owe it to him to try."
I look around at these four women - my friends, my chosen family - and feel something settle into place. "Then let's do it right."
We move to the sideboard, coffee in hand.
I reach for the oldest folder. The label reads: Richmond Baby, 1998.
It's thick. More pages than any of the others. Newspaper clippings. Photocopies of police reports. Notes in Bud's careful handwriting filling every margin.
“The Richmond Baby,” I read aloud. “What’s this one?”
Vonnie’s head snaps up. “Richmond?”
“You know it?” I ask.
“I know the names.” Vonnie sets down her coffee. “Katherine Richmond - the young mother. And Chad Carter, her ex-boyfriend. He was the baby’s father.”
The room goes instantly silent.
“Chad Carter died last week,” Linny says. “Car accident on Highway 85, just after the first snowfall. Missed a curve on the slick roads.”
Demi already has her phone out. “How long ago?”
“Thursday. Three days ago,” Vonnie says.
I stare at the folder in my hands. Chad Carter’s name is all over Bud’s notes, and he died just days ago.
“That’s…” I trail off.
“A sign,” Linny says softly. “From Bud, maybe. Or the universe.”
Martha nods. “We pick up this file, and one of the main people involved dies days before we open it? That doesn’t feel like a coincidence.”
“What does the file say? How was Chad Carter involved?” Demi asks, moving closer.
I open it. The first page is dated October 1998. Twenty-seven years ago, almost to the day.
“Baby girl reported missing from Katherine Richmond’s home,” I read aloud. “Katherine Richmond, age eighteen. Newborn daughter, Jane. Called Janey. Less than one week old, just home from the hospital.”
“God,” Martha whispers. “A newborn.”
I keep reading. "Katherine told police she was exhausted. Chad Carter offered to take the baby for a drive so Katherine could sleep. She agreed. Woke four hours later and no baby. Chad said he'd brought Janey back, put her in the crib while Katherine was sleeping, and left. But when Katherine checked the crib, it was empty."
Linny's face has gone pale. "I remember this. The whole town searched."
"Did they find her?" I ask, though Vonnie's face already tells me the answer.
"No." Linny's voice is barely audible. "They searched for about a week. Then the snow came down hard. Had to stop."
The next pages are police reports. Witness statements. Katherine's story, fragmented and desperate.
"Police questioned Katherine extensively," I say. "Her timeline was inconsistent. Times didn't match up. Details changed. She contradicted herself."
"She was eighteen, postpartum and terrified," Martha says. "Of course she was confused."
"They searched her house top to bottom," I continue, scanning Bud's notes. "Talked to her family, her neighbors. But they couldn't find any evidence she'd harmed the baby. And Katherine never wavered on the main point - Chad took Janey and never brought her back."
I turn the page. "That's when Chad's story started to matter more. He said he'd been around town that day. People confirmed seeing his truck at the gas station, outside the diner. And his best friend, Toby Fitzwilliams, backed him up. Said he was with Chad when Chad returned the baby."
"Toby Fitzwilliams," Vonnie says. "Everyone loves Toby. He took over Trailside Automotive when his dad passed. Reliable. Loyal. Good guy."
"So two young men vouched for each other," Martha says quietly. "Against one exhausted teenage mother."
I nod. "Katherine was sure that Chad never brought Janey back. But Chad pointed to the empty car seat in the house as proof. Said he'd returned the baby, tried to wake Katherine, but she was sleeping so deeply she didn't wake up. Said Janey was sleeping too, so he just put her in the crib and left."
"And people believed him?" I look up.
"Chad could be charming," Vonnie says. Her tone is careful. "When he wanted to be. Smooth talker. Always had an explanation for everything."
"You knew him?" I ask.
"Everyone knew Chad Carter. Grandview's not that big." Vonnie's expression is hard to read. "He was... complicated. Charming one minute, unreliable the next. Always had some scheme going. "He and Toby Fitzwilliams were inseparable. Chad was always at Trailside.""
Demi taps her phone screen. "Obituary says he was forty-seven. Never married. Worked in construction. Lived here his whole life."
Bud’s notes are next - more pages. His notes are meticulous. He documented everything. Search parties. Interviews. Timeline reconstructions.
One entry, dated two weeks after Janey disappeared:
Chad talks about this like it's already over. Like the case is closed. No panic. No desperation. No emotion... calm. Too calm.
Another note, from a month later:
People saw Chad's truck around town that day, but nobody actually saw Chad himself. Just the truck. Spotted at the gas station, outside the diner, even at Trailside. But nobody saw him - where was Chad? Strange.
"Bud didn't believe him," Martha says, reading over my shoulder.
I find the passage I'm looking for, near the middle of the file. Bud's handwriting, underlined:
Katherine is telling the truth. I'm sure of it. But I can't prove it. Chad's story holds. Toby backs him up. Two against one.
"He trusted Toby," I say.
"Everyone does," Linny confirms. "Toby and Chad were best friends. Had been since school. If Toby said he was with Chad, he was with Chad."
I turn to the last pages. The case went cold as winter deepened. No body found. No evidence of foul play. No way to prove what happened.
A final note from Bud, dated January 1999: Katherine left town today. She just turned nineteen. I don’t blame her. The whispers were getting worse. People wondering if she was negligent, if she let something happen to that baby. She couldn't stay.
"She lived with it for a few months," Martha says softly. "Holding out hope. Through Thanksgiving. Through Christmas. Through her nineteenth birthday. And then she left."
"Wouldn't you?" Vonnie asks. "Everyone looking at you like you lost your baby through carelessness?"
“Most people didn't think that.” Linny leans forward. "Most people felt terrible for her. But Katherine... she felt the judgment whether it was there or not."
I close the file. "So what do we do? Chad's dead. Katherine's been gone for twenty-seven years. Janey was never found."
"We investigate," Demi says. She's already making notes on her tablet. "We find out what Bud couldn't prove."
"Katherine might not want this dredged up," Vonnie points out gently. "She rebuilt her life somewhere else. We could be reopening old wounds."
"Then we find her first," Martha says. "We ask. If she doesn't want our help, we respect that."
I look around the table. These women are ready to chase a twenty-seven-year-old mystery for a man they respected and a baby they never knew.
"We start with what we have," I say. "Bud's notes and a timeline. We figure out what really happened that day."
"Agreed," Demi says.
"Agreed," Martha echoes.
Vonnie and Linny nod.
Axel lifts his head from under the table. This one's complicated.
"Probably."
I meet each woman's eyes in turn.
The Sunday Supper Society has officially begun.
Later, after everyone's gone and I've helped Martha load the dishwasher, I drive home with the Richmond Baby file on my passenger seat.
Axel sprawls in the back, his head resting on his paws.
You're quiet.
"Thinking."
About the baby?
"About everything." I turn onto the county road that leads to my farmhouse. "A newborn just... gone. And twenty-seven years later, we're the ones trying to figure out what happened."
Bud tried for twenty-seven years.
"I know."
He believed Katherine.
"I know that too."
The farmhouse comes into view. Lights on in the windows. My dad always said a dark house looked lonely, so I leave lamps on when I'm gone.
Inside, I spread the file across the kitchen table. Axel settles on the rug, watching me.
The pages are worn at the edges from Bud's handling. Notes stacked on notes. Questions circled. Timeline arrows connecting events.
October 1998. A teenage mother, exhausted and alone. A baby who vanished. A young man who stayed too composed.
A page near the back shows Bud's handwriting, faded, barely legible: Where did she go? Someone knows. Someone always knows.
The question has haunted this file for twenty-seven years.
And now Chad Carter is dead, taking his answers with him.
I sit back in my chair. Somewhere out there, Janey Richmond is twenty-seven years old. Unless she's not. Unless something terrible happened that October day and nobody ever found out.
Axel shifts on the rug. What are you thinking?
"I'm thinking about a baby who disappeared. And a mother who spent twenty-seven years not knowing what happened to her daughter."
And Chad Carter?
"Died before we could ask him anything. That's the tragedy of it. Whatever he knew, it's gone now."
I stack the pages carefully and close the file.
Outside, a cold wind picks up. Late October in North Dakota. Winter's close.
I lean back in my chair. The words arrive unbidden:
A baby, a lie, and the years,A mother's unanswered tears.The truth buried deep,While secrets we keep,Grow heavy with decades of fears.
Axel's ears twitch. That's sad.
"It is."
You going to tell the others?
"About the limerick? No."
Why not?
"Because they're just my brain's way of processing things. They don't mean anything."
If you say so.
I turn off the kitchen light and head upstairs.
Somewhere out there, Janey Richmond would be twenty-seven years old now. If she's alive. And if she is, does she know she’s adopted? Does she know there's a mother who never stopped wondering what happened to her?
Maybe Katherine Richmond is still out there too, still holding onto hope.
Maybe we can find answers Bud couldn't.
Maybe.