Chapter 1
Coming Home
Tuesday, December 8
Axel has opinions about glitter, and I make the mistake of answering him out loud.
"It is not a snack." I hold the jar over my head. "It's for ornaments."
It’s in a jar. Snacks come in jars, Axel informs me.
"Not these."
Every head in the Seniors' Drop-In Center turns my way. Three men at the jigsaw table freeze with puzzle pieces in the air.
"She reads him the labels," Linny announces, hauling a box of felt onto the nearest table. "He likes to know what's in things."
The men go back to their puzzle. One of them nods, and that settles it.
Only I hear Axel. To everyone else he’s a very large red poodle with an expressive face.
Linny Winfred runs the Tuesday craft hour here, which is why I'm here with her supplies. She's an artist, a knitter and a crocheter, and one of the four Queenagers who adopted me when I inherited my late uncle Bud's farm and moved to Grandview.
Less than two years ago I managed a veterinary clinic in Jupiter, Florida. Now I’m a retiree in North Dakota with a talking poodle, a cat who judges me, and a few solved murders that nobody remembers when they need an extra pair of hands to volunteer.
Today's project is felt ornaments for the Drop-In's courtyard spruce. Saturday night the town lights the big tree at the end of Main Street, and the Drop-In serves cocoa out back. By Friday our spruce has to look well loved.
A woman in a Vikings sweatshirt holds up a felt reindeer with no face. "Does he get eyes?"
"Everybody gets eyes," Linny assures her.
Linny presses a glue gun and a bag of felt eyes into my hands. "Now you're on eyes."
On a stepladder by the front window, a man in a canvas jacket staples garland above the glass. “Graham Vance,” Linny tells me. “He rebuilt the Drop-In’s front ramp last spring and is now handling the Christmas decorating. Cheap. He quoted the board half what anyone else would and asked if they could pay him by Friday.”
I set a big box on a folding table. The table wobbles.
Graham climbs down, walks over, folds a square of cardboard, and wedges it under the short leg. The table levels.
"Been meaning to do that since October," he says, as he climbs back up the ladder.
At a corner table, a man in a gray coat sits behind a folded newspaper, checking his watch, then the door, then his watch again. "Duncan Sinclair," Linny murmurs. "Chairs the Drop-In board. Tuesdays he signs whatever the accountant puts in front of him."
The accountant arrives ten minutes late, in a camel topcoat, carrying a manila folder as if it might be contagious. Arthur Finch keeps the Drop-In's books and, he'll tell you, half the county's.
"You're late," Duncan says.
"I'm busy." Arthur drops the folder on Duncan's table. "Do you know what December is for an accountant?"
Nobody does.
“Every business in this county remembers on the twenty-third that the thirty-first is coming. I have eleven year-end closes, and a client with a burned-down house who calls me hourly to ask where her money is."
He lifts one of the eyeless reindeer by the ear. "And I'm standing in a senior center looking at this. Is it a reindeer or a sock puppet?"
"Reindeer," Linny says, in a voice that could freeze soup.
"Of course it is."
I like him less than the glitter, Axel says from under the table.
I keep my mouth shut this time.
The front door opens again. A tall man in a long scarf holds it for a small woman in a good wool coat. Her silver hair is cut short, her gloves are buttoned at the wrist, and she checks the exits before she checks anyone's face.
"Dad?" The tall man stops. "Mom said you'd be at the office."
"Tuesday is checks." Duncan stays in his chair. "What are you doing here?"
"Aunt Grace wanted to see Grandma's table." The tall man trails the small woman toward the coffee urn. Half the room says hello. She answers each one by name and keeps walking.
She takes a snapshot from the corkboard near the coffee urn and carries it back toward our table. In the picture, an older woman sits at a card table, fanning five aces like a trophy. The small woman touches one corner with a gloved finger.
"Millie MacLeod. I drove her here to play cribbage," the small woman tells us, though we haven't asked. "Every Tuesday for ten years."
"Grandma cheated at cribbage," the tall man volunteers. "Everyone knew. Nobody said a word." Hazel and the other women chuckle and reminisce with them about Millie’s shenanigans.
He holds out a hand. "Tobias Sinclair. You're Bud Wilder's niece. Grandma told me once that Bud was the one man in Grandview who returned a casserole dish clean and on time."
"Willie," I say. "He'd be pleased."
"This is my Aunt Grace. Technically my mother's cousin, but when I was little 'first cousin once removed' was a lot to say."
"Grace Nicholson." She doesn't unbutton her coat. "Lovely to meet you. I'm visiting."
"For Christmas," Tobias says.
"For the day. We'll discuss Christmas."
He grins at the floor and kisses the top of her head. She allows it, then straightens his collar without looking, like someone who has done it a thousand times.
MacLeod. Nicholson. These names snag. Bud's bottom drawer, a file I skimmed a few times since we sorted through his old files.
Fifteen years in a drawer, and the people in it just walked through the front door.
Grace's eyes finish their tour of the room and stop on the camel topcoat.
"Arthur," she says.
"Grace." Arthur's pen stops over the folder.
"Arthur. Good." Tobias pulls a folded sheet from his coat. "I mailed you a copy of this three weeks ago. You said you'd look into it. I'd rather ask you about it here, with Aunt Grace listening, so nobody can say there’s another misunderstanding."
"Tobias, I have a desk full of—"
"Fifteen years ago I paid you to transfer Grandma's house into my name. I kept every receipt. Last spring Dad’s basement flooded and I helped him haul out his old files. I’ve been sorting through them and last month I found a second payment. From Dad, also to you." He holds up a photocopy of a check stub. I'm too far away to read it.
"Same month the house came to me. Same month Aunt Grace signed away her right to live in it. What was it for?"
"Fifteen years, Tobias. I'd need to pull the file." Arthur doesn't blink. "A fee, I'd guess. Drawing up the release, probably. Administrative."
"Tobias." Duncan doesn't raise his voice. He has probably never had to. "Not here."
"Where, Dad? I thought she left because she wanted to. Fifteen years I thought that."
"Tobias," Grace says. He stops.
Duncan folds his newspaper into precise thirds and heads for the door. "We'll discuss this at the house, with your mother."
"The checks," Arthur says.
"Tomorrow. At eleven."
He shoves the front door outward and it swings shut behind him. The coffee urn gurgles into the quiet.
"All the years I’ve known him," Linny whispers, "and I've never seen Duncan Sinclair leave a room that fast."
"Is it that unusual?"
"He once sat through a three-hour zoning hearing to avoid walking out in front of the mayor."
Graham has stopped stapling. He stands halfway up the ladder with the stapler against his chest, studying the garland with total concentration. He heard all of it. Everyone in the Drop-In heard all of it.
Then he climbs down, dusting his hands on his jeans. "Arthur. Since you're not signing checks, I've got a job for you."
"I have no time to spare."
"Tomorrow. Ten o’clock. The courtyard lights. My helper's down with the flu, and I need a second pair of hands out the side door. An hour, tops."
“I have eleven year-end closes.”
"A little work and I'm buying the coffee."
"We all gotta do our part, Arthur," one of the jigsaw men calls. Two women by the window nod. Arthur surveys the room, counts the faces, and knows he’s lost.
"One hour. Max."
"One hour," Graham says.
"And you're buying. The Friendly Corner’s coffee, not that urn."
"Not that urn," Graham agrees.
Arthur grabs his folder and shoulders the front door open. A woman in a red parka stands on the doorstep. She has no mittens and the expression of someone who has rehearsed a complaint since last week.
"Arthur."
"Annita." He doesn't slow. "I'll call."
"You said Thursday."
"And I will."
"You said that last Thursday."
"Then I'm behind." He is down the sidewalk before the door closes.
The woman comes in anyway, bringing the cold straight to our table. "Annita Davidson. She’s a fellow crafter," Linny tells me. "Her house burned down last month."
Graham already has a paper cup filled for her. He holds it out, and she takes it without looking at him. "Still on your sister's couch?"
"Until the insurance company stops losing paperwork and I can get Arthur’s attention long enough to send them copies."
"He'll be out the side door with me at ten tomorrow, if you want to catch him."
"Ten." She drinks half the cup standing. "I'll bring what’s still in my file."
I press a felt eye onto a reindeer and hold it while the glue grips.
The room restarts, one jigsaw piece at a time. I set the glue gun down, walk to the coffee urn, and carry a coffee over to Grace. Tobias walks with me with his own coffee in his hands. Grace has taken the card table by the window with her coat still buttoned. Tobias and I both sit and I hand her the coffee.
"I'm sorry," Tobias tells her. "I should have asked before I confronted Arthur."
"You had the conversation where I could hear it." She wraps both gloved hands around the cup. "That's the first time anyone has."
Axel crawls under the table until his chin rests on her boot. She doesn't push him off.
She looks over at me. “Your uncle was the only one who ever asked me what happened with Millie’s house. He drove to Millhaven. An hour each way, for a cup of tea.”
Her thumb traces the rim of the cup. "He believed me. Or he was being polite. I never could tell with Bud."
I don't mention the Bud’s file still in his filing cabinet drawer. She has wondered for fifteen years if anyone believed her, and I haven't read enough to promise anything.
By four I'm home and the light is going. The Wilder Side, the name my uncle gave the farmhouse, smells like woodsmoke and cold ashes. Dinner plans include a can of soup I intend to heat later and probably won't.
Bud's office is the converted mudroom off the kitchen. His lamp still sits on the desk with his reading glasses folded beside it.
I use the lamp. I can’t make myself put his glasses away. The bottom drawer of the filing cabinet holds three files now. I take the one labeled in Bud's slanted capitals: ‘Property Dispute.’
I carry the file out to the living room where Rowan controls Bud’s chair. Rowan’s a large orange Maine Coon cat with amber eyes. Martha rescued her and later lent her to me to help with a mouse problem. After she successfully completed her mission she announced she was staying.
There was no point in arguing with her then and there’s no point in arguing with her about the chair now. Instead, I take one end of the couch. Axel takes the other end.
That is a long time to hold a grudge, Rowan says. Even for a cat.
"Should I ask how you know that?"
She closes her eyes. Exchange over.
The top clipping in Bud’s file has gone the color of weak tea. NIECE CONTESTS RELEASE ON MacLEOD HOME, the headline says, over a photo of a younger Grace Nicholson with darker hair.
The story is short. Millie MacLeod left her house to her grandson, Tobias Sinclair, with a clause that let her niece, Grace Nicholson, live there for life. Grace signed that clause away, took a year of paid rent in Millhaven, and moved out.
Months later she was telling the weekly paper she'd been tricked, and the family's accountant was calling it a misunderstanding.
Behind the clippings, two index cards are stapled to the inside cover. Bud's cramped blue ballpoint, readable after all this time.
‘G.N. says A. Finch came to the house. Said the grandson needed it for his upcoming marriage and the family he wanted to start. She would receive a year’s rent elsewhere. Kinder to leave before anyone had to ask.’
‘A.F. says G.N. wanted out, tired of the house and upkeep, had friends in Millhaven. Rent was a courtesy from the family. Her idea start to finish.’
Across the bottom of the second card, he has underlined a note twice: ‘Same week. Same facts. Opposite stories. Somebody is lying and neither one blinked.’
I read it a third time. Today, with Tobias's photocopy in front of him, Arthur Finch hadn't blinked either.