Wine Tastings Are Murder

Book 5: Poppy McAllister Mystery

by Libby Klein

Genres: Craft & Hobby Cozy Mysteries; Culinary Cozy Mysteries

Synopsis

It's vintage Poppy when the gluten-free baker and B&B owner tries to solve a murder at a Cape May winery in Libby Klein's fifth deliciously witty, paleo-themed Poppy McAllister Mystery.



When Poppy and Aunt Ginny agreed to host a Wine and Cheese Happy Hour for a tour group at their Butterfly House Bed and Breakfast on the Jersey Shore, they never anticipated such a sour bunch. Grumpy guest Vince Baker should be in a better mood—he's filthy rich and on his honeymoon with his much younger wife Sunny, who seems to dote on him almost as much as her high-spirited teacup Pomeranian, Tammy Faye Baker.



But the honeymoon is over when Vince drops dead the next day touring the Laughing Gull Winery. Turns out he's been poisoned, and it seems like everybody on the tour is hiding something. Now Poppy has to put her gluten-free baking on the back burner and bottle up her feelings for the two men in her life while she charges after a bitter killer with a lethal case of sour grapes . . .

Release date: December 1, 2020

Publisher: Kensington Cozies

Print pages: 254

Sample

Kale frittata is proof that I’ll eat anything if it has enough cheese in it. I’d read on the Internet that a famous celebrity lost fifty pounds on the kale diet, so I thought it was foolproof. It was like eating an omelet full of yard clippings. I’d lost nothing in the nine days of my sentence, and I was starting to think the secret to celebrity weight loss was starvation, because right now I’d rather eat nothing than another forkful of misery.

I should have been further along with my workout this morning, but I was dragging. The sun was already bobbing in the Atlantic like an abandoned pink beach ball. I’d been seeing a crunchy doctor of Alternative Wellness since returning to Cape May six months ago. She was convinced I was sick because my body was under stress, and she wanted me only doing yoga. She would not approve of my six a.m. tromp down the boardwalk on very little sleep any more than my current Hollywood crackpot nutrition plan. But then Dr. Melinda wasn’t overweight and didn’t have two men wooing her for a romantic commitment. At least not that I knew of. Maybe she did. The topic never came up when she was lecturing me about sleeping more and trying to get healthy instead of trying to get skinny. All advice that I was currently ignoring in my desperate push to look good in lingerie without investing in blackout drapes. Not that anything was happening, mind you. But if the opportunity were to arise, I wanted to be prepared.

I made a hundred-and-eighty-degree turn where the cement promenade smacked into the beach grass and started the mile-and-a-half trudge back toward home. The salt air stung my eyes but not my resolve. Recent amorous declarations had given me a burst of nervous energy to fight through the wind rolling in on the crashing surf. Gia and Tim had both said they loved me, and I was sure that I loved them. Choosing was like cutting my heart in half, but it had to be done. I’d tried stalling over Valentine’s Day, but that just made me feel icky, like I was stringing one of them along. If only I could figure out which one. You only get to fall in love so many times in your life. Why did I have to lump mine together? I wasn’t made for drama.

“On your left!” I took a step to the right of the path and an elderly couple out power walking lapped me in a swish of nylon from their matching yellow tracksuits. I picked up my pace—not because my pride was poked but because I was interval training. Starting now.

The houses across from the ocean on the other side of Beach Drive were getting ready for the tourist season. Flower boxes were being filled with pansies. Red, white, and blue bunting was being draped across awnings, and Keep Out—Private Property signs were being repositioned at the edges of driveways by those residents who were less enthusiastic about the hordes destined to descend on Cape May for our sand, surf, and seafood. As a plus-size redhead, my teen years on the island had been more of the study, shame, and sunburn variety. It was twenty-five years later, and I was back, launching the debut season of the Butterfly Wings Bed and Breakfast in Aunt Ginny’s three-story Victorian. I had to store our own Keep Out sign in the garage next to Aunt Ginny’s statue of a garden gnome mooning the neighbors.

A tiny little twentysomething in a coast guard T-shirt jogged past me, her brunette ponytail swishing side to side with the rhythm of her steps. Self-pity made its customary move to squeeze my heart, but I dodged it with the positive affirmations I’d been practicing: I’m good enough just the way I am. I am beautiful, strong, intelligent, and amazing. I don’t have to be skinny to be loved. Any man would be lucky to have me. That last bit wasn’t supposed to derail me into a different obsession, but my mind was like the teacup ride on Morey’s Pier and I spun around to the soap opera that was playing on channel two.

I just wanted a life full of passion. Was that so much to ask? I had twenty years with an amazing husband who was the best friend I could ever want. John was everything a husband should be—patient, kind, generous—but we skipped over all the fun stuff at the beginning. Where you can’t eat, can’t sleep, and your heart speeds up and your stomach bottoms out when he’s near. The total infatuation when you first fall for someone and you fall hard. We missed it entirely. We went from friendship to peach schnapps to pregnancy test to blue-light special bridal registry at Kmart. If he wasn’t so amazing our next step after miscarriage would have been Divorce Court. What a life we had until.... At least he’s not suffering anymore. He hung on until his mother said she was moving in with us to take care of him. I think that’s all he needed to let go.

Tim and I, however, had the fun stuff; we just never had anything else. We were high school sweethearts—all passion and plans for the future with none of the bills or taxes or fights over who took out the trash last. My relationship with Tim ended . . . abruptly. I reference you to the aforementioned peach schnapps. Could we start life over as if college had never happened? Now was our chance to recapture that passion and see if it had wings. But once again, fate had sabotaged our plans. This time, his name was Giampaolo.

Gia was passion in pinstripes. Just being near him made me all giggly. When he brings me coffee and calls me Bella it’s all I can do to remember Tim’s name. I had no doubt that the honeymoon phase with Gia would be fantastic, but was there enough there to get us through the sick, poor, cranky side of life? What will happen when Gia finds out I snore? Or that I don’t wake up with this makeup on? How could I hold his attention when gorgeous young girls threw themselves at him every day?

I didn’t want a comfortable life. I’d had that. I wanted electricity. I wanted to be swept off my feet. Just once I’d like a fairy-tale romance. Everyone says trust your instincts and choose, but my instincts had always been wrong. Again—schnapps. I knew this decision would change everything. I was about to set fire to some bridges, and I’d have to live with the consequences. As much as I’d like to, I couldn’t stall any longer. It was time to light the match.

I heard the tango music from around the corner. I thought maybe Mr. Winston was watching Masterpiece Mystery! with his morning Danish. He loved his British mysteries. The whole street knew when PBS was running a Midsomer Murders marathon. Mr. Winston vowed not to get a hearing aid until he couldn’t adjust the TV volume any higher. When I passed the Butterfly Wings B&B shingle in the yard, I was surprised that the music got louder. It wasn’t coming from Mr. Winston’s. It was coming from inside my house.

“What in the world are you two doing?”

Aunt Ginny was in the peach and copper kitchen wearing a floor-length black dress with a red rose running down the side into three rows of ruffles. Her Sharon Osbourne red hair was slicked back, and she had dark eyeliner sketched in crooked lines past the corners of her eyelids. She was holding Figaro against her face, his whiskers to her cheek, his orange eyes aflame with alarm. He was clearly not so much into this plan.

Aunt Ginny dipped Fig and he slid panicked eyes to mine. “We’re celebrating!”

I reached the boom box and turned the knob down until the stemware stopped shaking. “Both of you?”

“Of course.”

Figaro flicked his tail toward me like he was reaching for a lifeline.

“How’d you convince him to wear the bow tie?”

Aunt Ginny held his paw out and they did a few steps toward the sink. She grabbed a cat treat and popped it into Fig’s mouth, spun around and led him back toward me. “It was his idea.”

Of course it was. “And just what are you celebrating?”

Aunt Ginny slid her leg out to the side and did a low lunge. Figaro reached his free paw and swatted at the second pile of cat treats on the island. When Aunt Ginny dipped him for the finale, she pulled a paper from her cleavage. “Dingdong the bat is gone.”

I took the letter from Aunt Ginny’s hands and unfolded it. “Dear Ms. McAllister, I regret to inform you,” yada yada yada. Mrs. Galbraith had formally tendered her resignation.

Aunt Ginny let Figaro down and opened a can of minced crab. “I found it next to the coffeepot with her key to the side door when I had breakfast this morning.”

“This says she’s not just quitting our house; she’s leaving the cleaning service permanently.”

Aunt Ginny grinned showing two rows of pearly white dentures.

“She says stress and high anxiety have forced her into early retirement.” I dealt Aunt Ginny a you know what you did look, and she raised me with a prim shrug.

“No matter how breezy you’re acting, I know you know you caused this.”

“Now Figaro will have the freedom to run the house again.”

Figaro looked from Aunt Ginny to me while open-mouth chomping on a piece of crabmeat.

I sighed and folded the letter back up and put it in the mail basket to file later. “Now I have to hire a new chambermaid before Wednesday. That newlywed couple is arriving in three days for the South Jersey Wine Tour and we have a few weekend bookings leading up to Memorial Day.”

Aunt Ginny got the coffee beans down and handed them to me, her idea of a subtle hint. “Try to find someone with a better temperament this time. Someone who won’t act like we’re crazy for every little request.”

I filled the kettle with water and forced myself not to roll my eyes.”I don’t think we’ll find anyone willing to curtsy and call you mum.”

“I said ‘the Dowager Frankowski’ was close enough. I’m not unreasonable. And while we’re on the subject of dying old and alone.”

“No.”

“Oh, come on.”

“Nope.”

“Just tell me who you’re going to pick.”

“I’m not talking to you about this.”

“If I find out from those busybodies at the Senior Center, I’ll never forgive you.”

“If they’re such terrible busybodies then why do you hang out with them?”

“They’re my best friends.”

I raised an eyebrow at the Dowager and hit the button on the coffee grinder. After thirty seconds it made the high-pitched whirring sound of finishing its task. I flicked my eyes to her “Addicted to Love” hairstyle. “Is that my new anti-frizz gel?”

Aunt Ginny grabbed two coffee mugs and set them on the counter. “No. . . . It’s Vaseline.”

“Have fun washing that out.”

“I don’t have to, smarty-pants. I’m getting my hair dyed today. This will be Yolanda’s problem in about an hour.”

“I hope you’re a good tipper.”

“That reminds me. While I’m gone, will you set up my new doohickey?”

“You’re going to have to be more specific.”

Aunt Ginny pointed with two stevia packets to a box sitting by the cookie jar. “Royce bought me something called a Zalexa to make my life easier.”

I almost dropped the kettle. The last thing Aunt Ginny needed was more free time. Her high school boyfriend had returned a few weeks ago and he’d been turning our lives upside down from the moment Broadway spit him out in Cape May. I was all for eighty-year-olds going “a-courting,” but Royce Hansen had the short-term memory of a fruit fly and Aunt Ginny could do crazy all on her own. “I’ll do what I can, but I’ll be at Maxine’s making desserts for Tim most of the day.”

“So, it’s Tim then?”

I set the time for the coffee press. “I didn’t say that.Tomorrow I’ll be at Gia’s to do the gluten-free baking.”

Aunt Ginny handed me her cup and gave me a dubious eyebrow raise. “How do you think the loser will react when you tell him?”

I wanted to ask if the loser was the one who gets me or the one who dodges this crazy train, but the whole concept of there being a winner and a loser seemed ridiculous, and I blinked it away. “We’re all adults. I’m sure everyone will carry on with their lives no matter what happens.... Right?”

“Oh, honey.” Aunt Ginny snickered and shook her head. “I’ve been married five times and never once did any man whose heart I had to break carry on like nothing happened. You mark my words; this will be a spectacular train wreck.”

I wound my little Toyota through streets packed with rows of gingerbread cottages and Victorian mansions over to the harbor. The first few days of March had been cold and rainy, but today the sun was glittering off the water like fairy lights. Squalls were common here being set off the southern tip of New Jersey in the Atlantic, and the rainbow horizon of windsocks shot out like soldiers at full salute warning would-be sailors of dangerous gusts.

Maxine’s was a tiny little cottage nestled in the heart of the harbor flanked by million-dollar condos and Cape May Yacht Tours. Tim was out front hanging a giant red wooden crab on the white clapboard in between the blue awnings. The wind was whipping his black T-shirt up exposing a flat stomach with just the beginning pouf of love handles. He tossed me a cheesy grin matching the one on the crab when my tires crunched onto the crushed clamshells of the parking lot.

I parked and he waved me over to inspect his handiwork. “What do you think?”

“It’s a giant crab wearing a pearl necklace.”

“It’s the new Maxine.” He gave me an excited smile. “Isn’t she a doll?”

“Maxine” was the size of a radial tire, with blue eyes and blond curly hair. She had a coy smile that was both eerily familiar and unsettling at the same time. “Uh-huh. Well, she’s got your eyes, but I thought Maxine was an invisible classy French lady.”

Tim shrugged. “The Lobster House has its topless mermaid, the Crab House has its one-legged sea captain, and Urie’s has its palm trees. It’s Cape May kitsch. Tourists are gonna love her.”

I took one more look at the perky crab and icy fingers tickled up my spine. Well, she’s creeping me out.

Tim was oblivious to my wariness and pulled me in for a proper kiss. “Hello, gorgeous. Are you here to make my dreams come true?”

“Are your dreams about Nutella Crème Brûlée and Piña Colada Cake?”

Tim pulled back in mock horror. “How did you know?”

“That French rolling pin I left here is bugged.”

Tim grabbed his chest. “Mon Dieu!” He led me in the front door, and we passed through the blue and white dining room that still smelled like rosemary from last night’s lamb roast.

The front-end manager was setting new vases of apricot roses on every table and checking the silverware for spots. “Hey, Poppy.”

“Hey, Linda.”

A kerfuffle was in full swing in the kitchen, as Chuck was in a very heated hockey debate. “Chef! Tell the new guy here that there’s no way the Penguins are going to knock out the Flyers in the play-offs. Giroux is hot right now!”

A shaggy blond in chef whites shook his head. “The Penguins are having a better season. I’m telling you, brah, they’re gonna take it.”

Tim pointed toward the door. “Tyler. You’re fired.”

Tyler threw his arms out dramatically and protested while Chuck threw an apron at him. “Told you.”

The kitchen was prepping for the day’s lunch and dinner services. Juan was hauling trays of shellfish from the walk-in to the sink, Tyler got back to his station of chopping vegetables, and Tim checked on what smelled like scallop stock he had simmering for the soup of the day.

I reached for my apron and Chuck hustled back in to hand me a double espresso. “Here you go, Chef Poppy.”

I gratefully took the demitasse cup from him. “You don’t have to call me Chef, Chuck.”

Chuck grinned. “Are you making those Peanut Butter Mousse pies today?”

“I thought I’d make a couple, yes.”

“Then you get to be called Chef.”

“Chuck!” Tim called from around the corner. “Stop flirting with Poppy and get back to work.”

Chuck, who was about twenty years younger than me, grinned again and blushed up to his eyebrows. “I better go. You know how he is.”

“Oh yeah.”

Tim came around the corner holding something behind his back. “I’ve got something for you.”

“Ooh, a present?”

He held his arm out and handed me a pink chef coat with my name embroidered over the breast pocket.

“It’s beautiful. Thank you!”

“You’re part of the team now. Go put it on.”

My heart started beating a familiar dirge—it’s gonna be too small; it’s gonna be too small. “Uh . . . okay.”

“You can use my office.”

Tim’s office was a jumbled mess of logbooks, invoices, and a mostly empty bag of Doritos. There was a whiteboard with Maxine’s hours of operation and employees’ names with notes about who wanted off when scribbled in the margins. I looked at the tag inside the uniform. The jacket was a size smaller than what I usually wore, and I thought about staging an emergency evacuation. Tim seemed to have absolutely no idea that I had gained weight since high school. I think his image of me was cached like the chef supply website he visited daily. I pulled off my long-sleeved blouse down to my tank top. If I was going to fit into this chef coat, I needed every millimeter of space I could make. I promised God I’d never eat ice cream again if he made this miraculously fit. I prayed the pink jacket over my head and shoulders, then begged it down to my waist. It was a bit snug in the northern hemisphere. I don’t care what Dr. Melinda thinks. I’ve got to turn up the workouts if I’m going to get this weight off fast. I considered taking the padding out of my bra to make space but decided my push-ups just gave me a little tent action over the breadbasket. Whoever designed chef uniforms must have used SpongeBob as their prototype. Everyone looks like a box.

Tim was waiting for me in the hall. “That looks good on you.”

Those aren’t the words I would use. That looks like you’ve stuffed yourself in a pink legwarmer feels more realistic. I cocked my elbow and gave a little runway strut. “You don’t think it’s a little small?”

“Oh no. It’s tight in all the right places.” His eyes bored into where Chef Poppy was being stretched out and my face went all warm and prickly. “I don’t know if I want you wearing that in front of the line. Chuck has already asked if this is serious, and I think Juan’s looking for a new green card.”

I giggled in spite of myself. “You’re being ridiculous.”

Tim pulled me against him. “Am I? How am I supposed to get any work done looking at you across the room in this?”

I giggled. “I don’t know. I guess you’ll have to realize that I’m middle-aged and that this uniform is probably two sizes too small.”

Tim nuzzled my neck. “Now who’s being ridiculous. I can’t wait until you’re here every day working for me.”

That dropped like a rock in my belly. “Tim, I would love to be here every day working with you, but you know the bed and breakfast is about to get very busy. I’ve had a PR company working on fixing the damage from last month’s attack with all those bogus bad reviews. And we just started working with a tour company that does custom theme weekends. I’m going to be stretched too thin.” At least my time will be.

Tim didn’t so much as pause. “We’ll work it out. Don’t worry.”

But I did worry. I worried about paying my bills and taking care of Aunt Ginny. I worried about hurting Tim and leaving him in the lurch. I worried my way through four hours of crafting cakes, custards, and mousse. I worried through Chuck stealing my spatula so he could get an early sample of peanut butter pie. And I worried myself all the way home to conduct the new chambermaid interviews where I discovered my worry was not in vain.

While I was gone, Aunt Ginny had scheduled six applicants all to arrive at the same time and was currently interrogating them en masse. It had all the earmarks of a hostage situation.

“I will not tolerate any shenanigans on those hickey-doos! Do you understand?”

Aunt Ginny had the six young ladies tightly packed on a four-person sofa in the wood-paneled library. She had changed into khaki pants, a white T-shirt, and a faded olive army jacket that I was pretty sure I’d seen in the attic yesterday next to her fox stole and three of her wedding dresses. She was pacing back and forth in front of the sofa with her hands clasped behind her back like General Sherman. Figaro, always willing to be the menacing backup, sat on the coffee table grilling the ladies and flicking his tail like a switchblade.

“If I catch you playing on your phone, I will confiscate it and you will show me how to play the game. You will not get it back until the end of the day after I have beaten your high score.”

The ladies were all from parts of Eastern Europe who came to Cape May every year on work visas. I had no doubt their English lessons had not prepared them for shenanigans or hickey-doos.

One of them was cowering into the throw pillows biting a hangnail. Another was hugging herself and gently rocking back and forth. One of the girls in the middle was watching Figaro like she thought he would sprout horns and strike at any minute; her eyes were the size of quarters behind her thick glasses.

“You are not to chat with anyone named Keith. Keith is a stupid name.”

The brunette on the other end of the couch was shaking her head and muttering to herself.

“You are never to turn the television off when I am in the room. I am not sleeping; I am just resting my eyes. If you turn off my program, I’ll take a switch to you.”

Uh-oh. The girl with the hangnails just crossed herself.

Aunt Ginny stopped pacing and pointed her finger at the girls. “And above all, if you find ajar of peanut butter hidden anywhere in this house you are to bring it to me at once. I’ve hidden one and I can’t remember where it is. And don’t let Poppy know where you found it. I may want to use that spot again.”

The girls all looked around Aunt Ginny to where I was standing in the archway, still in my pink chef bustier.

Aunt Ginny followed their eyes and jumped when she saw me. “Oh, Poppy. When did you get here?”

Figaro flopped over and accidentally slid off the coffee table and landed on the floor. The nervous girl in the middle of the sofa let out a little squeak and pulled her knees up to her chest hugging them tight against her.

I stepped into the library and scanned the girls’ faces before looking back at Staff Sergeant Frankowski. Her green coat had a patch with the name Wyatt sewn over the breast pocket. Her second husband. “What’s going on?”

Aunt Ginny gave me a toothy smile. “I was just doing some preliminary interviews.” She turned her head away from the girls and gritted her teeth. “To weed out the weak ones.”

“Uh-huh. And just how does that work?”

Aunt Ginny turned to the girls again. “Okay, anyone no longer interested in the position may go.”

The girls fought each other to get off the couch, through the library, and out the door like hikers running from a hatchet-wielding bear. Only one girl remained on the sofa. She was pale and thin and had long straight black hair and large blue eyes over high cheekbones. She gave me a timid smile.

“What’s your name?”

The girl held out a delicate hand and spoke in a clipped, lilting voice. “Victoryna Rostyslavivna Yevtushenko.”

Aunt Ginny flicked her eyes to mine. “Did you get that?”

The girl shook my hand like she was shaking up a Yoo-hoo. “You may call me Victory.”

“Well, Victory,” I said, pulling my hand gently from hers. “It looks like you’ve got the job.”

Victory did a fist pump. “Yes. And what ees job?”

I narrowed my eyes at Aunt Ginny. “What did you tell the service when you called?”

Aunt Ginny shrugged. “I said send me some foreign girls who like to work.”

I sucked in some air and let it out to the count of five. “We are looking for a chambermaid to clean the rooms and do laundry. Are you interested in doing that, Victory?”

“Yes, yes. I can do thees. I have J-1 visa.”

A beeping started from somewhere down the hall. I stuck my head out of the library and looked toward the kitchen. “What’s that noise?”

Aunt Ginny tossed her head. “I don’t know. I was talking to it earlier, but I didn’t tell it to beep like we were under attack.”

The three of us and Figaro followed the sound to the kitchen where Aunt Ginny’s new Alexa device was flashing.

Aunt Ginny looked at me. “Why is it doing that?”

“I don’t know. Alexa, what are you doing?”

The device paused the alarm to answer me. “I’m waiting to answer your questions.” The alarm sounded again.

“Alexa, what’s that noise?”

“What’s That Noise? is the first album from Coldcut.”

Alexa continued her long-winded answer and I finally cut in and said, “Alexa, stop.”

The alarm stopped and Victory pointed to the device. “Ees theis going off all of time?”

Since the Alexa personal assistant had only been installed for seven hours, I had no idea. “I’m sure it’s just a fluke.”

Aunt Ginny shook her head. “It probably won’t happ. . .