A true-crime fanatic uncovers a nefarious secret when she takes a peculiar cat-sitting assignment in this chilling suspense novel from the author of Peter Miles Has to Die.
Annie’s life is going nowhere—she’s in her thirties and getting by with cat-sitting jobs. While her clients head off on exotic beach holidays, Annie is left scooping litter and wondering how she ended up as the spectator in other people’s lives. Her one sliver of excitement is Cuppa Crime, a true crime podcast with an active online forum where she obsessively dissects murder mysteries with other fans. That is until a new client, Zoe, reaches out to book Annie’s services.
Zoe is aloof and mysterious, and she seems intent on keeping it that way. She gives Annie access to her glamourous house and handwritten instructions on how to look after her darling cat, Hades—all without meeting, or speaking, in person. Soon into the gig, Annie is vicariously living through the client she’s never met, her imagination running wild with the possibilities of inhabiting another life.
And yet something feels wrong about the house. It’s not just the closed-off room Annie is explicitly forbidden from entering. When odd souvenirs begin to pop up in Zoe’s home—souvenirs that seem connected to ongoing murder investigations—Annie suspects that there may be a more sinister side to her client.
Is it all in Annie’s head, the product of too much true crime and an overactive imagination? Or are her instincts on point? Because the number one rule of Cuppa Crime is "trust your gut." And if Annie’s gut is telling her anything, it’s that her cat-sitting client is a serial killer.
Release date:
November 10, 2026
Publisher:
Bantam
Print pages:
304
* BingeBooks earns revenue from qualifying purchases as an Amazon Associate as well as from other retail partners.
He lies at the end of the sofa, trapped in a pool of yellow light cast by the nearby standing lamp. Shifting from one foot to the other, I try to work up the nerve to cross the room and check if he’s breathing. Press my palm to his rib cage. Or is it two fingers on the neck, like in the movies? I sniff. The faint scent of rot lurks, a character standing just offstage. A soft, consistent buzz is the soundtrack to the scene. The tension in my shoulders tightens.
If he is dead . . . who should I call? Deborah’s on a flight halfway to Costa Rica right now. I picture the police entering her house, guns drawn. Me standing over Jeremy’s prostrate body, hands in the air, I didn’t do it, officers! I swear!
A soft creak brings my gaze to the ceiling.
Gary: It’s just the house settling, Annie.
Gail: Or . . . there’s a killer in the house. With you!
I shake my head and move a few steps farther into the room. The buzz grows slightly louder, setting my teeth on edge. I search for circling flies, for maggots digging into Jeremy’s bare skin. A second later, I realize the sound is coming from the lamp, not the body.
Another creak overhead. Then I see it, so fast and subtle I almost miss it: Jeremy’s ear twitches. A fog clears and the lamplight transforms from harsh to warm, the room from sinister to cozy. I laugh softly to myself.
As I backtrack to the foyer to hang my tote, I wonder if every day is going to be like this. With a shudder, I remember stroking Jeremy’s puckered patches of bare skin yesterday, gripping my everything’s going to be fine smile like someone might try to peel it off my face. Meanwhile, Deborah had droned on and on about the various medications needed to keep Jeremy’s exhausted organs chugging along.
I should have emergency exited the situation the minute she told me Jeremy’s the ripe old age of twenty-three.
Gary: No cat should live that long.
Gail: It’s not natural.
At least she’s paying me more than my standard fifteen dollars per visit for the added care her geriatric pet might require. My anemic checking account needs all the help it can get. I just have to keep Jeremy alive for the next two weeks and I’ll be able to pocket a nice, plump paycheck.
The neurotic barrage of messages is enough to convince me Deborah won’t be a repeat customer anyway. One and done. She’s already left me a dozen today, the time stamp on her latest reading 13:58 p.m., a few minutes shy of her flight leaving:
Taking off PLEASE text if you have any Qs I look forward to hearing from you later today!! Give Jeremy extra cuddles from me!!
I couldn’t help but picture Deborah in a cramped airplane seat furiously texting while an irritated flight attendant repeated for the fifteenth time, “Ma’am, you need to put your phone away for takeoff.”
A stack of mail on the wall-mounted table by the door draws my attention and I rummage through it, unearthing a few more facts about Deborah. Like that her middle name is Madeline, she makes regular donations to the ASPCA, and she has a subscription to Town & Country. The last one is the weirdest. I wouldn’t have pegged my disheveled client as the type.
The rest of her foyer is as cluttered as the living room, stacks of magazines dotting the area like faulty towers ready to topple at the slightest breeze. I scan the spines. The New Yorker, Time Magazine, and more Town & Country. An ashtray as big as my face sits atop one teetering pile. I poke through the spare keys, coins, batteries, and other odds and ends, then pick up the black lipstick tube and uncap it. The uninspiring nude shade is worn down almost flat. Couture Beige, I read off the bottom—a drugstore makeup brand’s attempt at sounding high-end.
I snap the cap back on and pocket it, then turn my attention to the staircase on my left. Should I go explore Deborah’s bathroom cabinet now, or save it as a treat for later? Her overstuffed closet is tempting, too. I’d seen it when she showed me the second-floor litter box yesterday. Luckily, there’s another on the first floor because I can’t imagine horizontal-on-the-sofa Jeremy climbing those stairs. I can, however, picture Deborah ascending them to bed every night, the cat tucked under her arm like a baguette.
Gary: Not a service we plan on providing, Deborah.
The clothes had pressed through the gap of the partially closed door—a stray jacket arm here, a wayward pant leg there—as if trying to escape. Her closet is in desperate need of a Goodwill run to relieve its bloating.
Gail: Or, you could help relieve its bloating. Temporarily, of course.
I spot a scarf hanging from one of the coat hooks by the door, half hidden by a green cardigan, and backtrack to pull it out. It’s soft, maybe cashmere. Circling the cream fabric around my shoulders, I bury my face in its folds. It smells like what I imagine a Christmas cabin would smell like, based off the Netflix holiday films I’ve hate-watched over the years.
Before I can overthink it, I stuff the scarf into my tote. My heart skips. The only thing of value I’ve ever failed to return was a blue clay sculpture in the shape of a giant toe. When I first saw it while cat sitting a temperamental calico named Mrs. Dalloway and her dopey tabby brother, Monsieur Dumas (god, those names), I couldn’t resist. It was too weird not to take home. Oddly, Mrs. Dalloway’s and Monsieur Dumas’s owners didn’t seem to notice its absence. They continued to employ me as a sitter for a year after that, and I decided to keep the toe. The appendage currently lives under my bed in the box—my treasure trove of items clients would never miss.
That’s where Deborah’s Couture Beige lipstick is going when I get home.
•
I’m in the kitchen, scraping the crushed pills into Jeremy’s bowl of wet food, when a series of creaks overhead makes me stop.
Again, my eyes snap to the ceiling.
Creak.
My pulse stutters.
Creak.
I tiptoe to the foyer and dig the pepper spray from my tote.
Creak. Creak.
As I look toward the top of the stairs, my mind goes back to a podcast episode I’d listened to a few weeks ago about worry. What had they said? That around 90 percent of things people fret about never come true?
Gary: This is just one of the 90 percent, Annie.
Gail: Or the 10 percent!
The butterflies in my stomach become more enthused with every step I take up the stairs. At the top, I stop. The bathroom sits at the end of the landing, the door wide open. The shower curtain is pushed all the way back, sparing me the cliche of tiptoeing up and dramatically shoving it aside, only to discover there’s no one hiding in the bathtub. I clock details I hadn’t seen before when Deborah gave me a tour. The black mold spreading from the scuffed baseboard on one side of the hall, the large daddy longlegs crouched on a web above the bathroom door.
The hallway folds around behind to three rooms at the opposite end: Deborah’s bedroom, a guest room, and an office.
One hand gripping the banister, the other my pepper spray, I face that end of the hall and catch a flicker of movement through the half-open office door. Another very clear creak follows.
I’ve made a mistake.
Gary: I think there’s actually someone here, Annie.
Gail: Run! Get out of this house! Call the police!
But I’m frozen in place. The buzzing from the lamp downstairs has transferred to my brain. Did I really just see that? Somehow, the idea of overreacting and there being no one here seems worse than if there is someone in the house with me. Taking a deep breath, I force my feet forward. The silence tightens like a straitjacket. Another step and the floorboard groans, this time beneath my weight. I might as well have fired a gun. Rapid creaks cross the room, clearly footsteps this time. Before I can turn and run, the door flings back, the knob hitting the wall with a harsh thunk. A large, dark figure materializes, backlit by the window behind.
It happens fast. It lunges in my direction with the words “Who the f*** are—”
I don’t let him finish. Without a second thought, I scream and release a torrent of pepper spray.
We hope you are enjoying the book so far. To continue reading...