The Last Kashmiri Rose

Book 1: A Detective Joe Sandilands Novel

by Barbara Cleverly

Genres: Historical Mysteries; International Crime & Mystery; Traditional Mysteries

Synopsis

India, 1922. In Panikhat, 50 miles from Calcutta, the wives of officers in the Bengal Greys have been dying violently, one every year and always in March. All the deaths are bizarre and seem accidental. The only link between them is the small red roses that mysteriously appear on the women’s graves on the anniversaries of their deaths. The first victim perished in a fire, the second was bitten by a cobra, another was thrown off her horse into a ravine, while the fourth drowned. When the fifth, the pretty young wife of Captain Somersham, is found with her wrists cut, the Governor of Bengal refuses to accept a suicide verdict and calls for help from the reluctant Joe Sandilands, currently on secondment to the Bengal police.

Release date: August 9, 2011

Publisher: Soho Crime

Print pages: 288

Sample

Chapter One
Bengal 1910

The night before her sixth birthday Midge Prentice woke
under her mosquito net and breathed the familiar smells of a
hot Indian night. There was the smell of wet khaskhas
mats hanging across the doors and windows to keep out the heat of
early summer, sweet and musty; there was the smell of the
jasmine which grew over the bungalow; there was the bass
accompaniment inseparable from India of drains and of
dung. But tonight there was something else.

Sharp and acrid, it was the smell of smoke. Midge sat up and
looked about her. Running across the ceiling of her room there
was a flickering reflection of flames. She struggled out of her
mosquito net and, barefoot, stood down on the floor. She called
for her father and then remembered he was away in Calcutta.
She called for her mother but it was Ayah who answered her call.

‘Come with Ayah, now, Missy Baba,’ she said urgently. ‘Come swiftly.
Be silent!’

Ayah gathered her up. ‘Put your arms round me and hold
tight. Very tight. Put your feet on mine and we’ll walk together
as we used to when you were a baby and then the bad, bad
men won’t see my Missy Baba. If I hide you under my sari
they’ll just think that Ayah has another baby on the way.’

She swept silky folds over Midge’s head and they set off to
waddle together towards safety. They had often done this
before; it had been a game of her infancy. It was called ‘elephant
walk backwards’ and now this clumsy game was to save
her life. Midge caught brief glimpses of Ayah’s sandalled feet
and was aware of others milling protectively about them and
then they were in the open air. They were free of the bungalow.
Men’s voices – Indian voices – shouted harshly, shots rang
out, a woman’s scream was abruptly cut short and then the
roar of the fire as it took hold of the thatch grew deafening.

But then, gravel was crunching under Ayah’s feet and she
stopped. ‘Sit here,’ she said. ‘Sit here and keep quiet. Don’t
move. Be hidden.’ And she tucked Midge away amongst the
rank of tall earthenware pots overflowing with bougainvillea
and zinnia.

 
In the mess, half a mile away, Jonno crossed and uncrossed his
legs under the table and with a slightly unsteady hand poured
himself a glass of port and passed the decanter. He was thinking
– he was often thinking – of Dolly Prentice, or, more formally,
Mrs Major Prentice. He was sure he hadn’t imagined
that, as he had helped her into her wrap after the gymkhana
dance, she had leant back against him, not obviously but perceptibly.
Yes, surely perceptibly. And his hands had rested on
her shoulders, slightly moist because it had been a hot night,
and there had been a warm female scent. What was it she had
said when, greatly daring, he had admired? ‘Chypre.’ Yes, that
was it – ‘Chypre.’

And that wasn’t all. They had danced close. Not difficult
when doing a two-step and she had said, almost out of the
blue, ‘You’re getting to be quite a big boy now.’ It might have
meant anything; it might have meant nothing.
But he didn’t think so. In memory he held that slender figure in its red chiffon
dress as close as he dared.

The young subaltern on Jonno’s left was also thinking of
Dolly Prentice. He knew she’d only been joking but she had
said, ‘Just bring your problems to me, young man, and I’ll see
what I can do.’ Had she meant it? He thought probably not.
But it had been accompanied by a steady and speaking glance
and, after his third glass of port, he decided, nevertheless, to
take her at her word.

That bloody pony! Fifty pounds! He hadn’t got fifty pounds!
Why had he fallen for it? He knew only too well why. He’d
been goaded into it by Prentice. ‘Take it or leave it. Pony’s
yours for fifty pounds but be warned – he takes a bit of riding!’
And the clear implication – ‘Too much of a handful for you!’
He thought if he threw himself on Dolly’s mercy, she might
intercede for him – get him off his bargain. Perhaps she could
persuade her husband not to take advantage of a young and
inexperienced officer? He didn’t like appearing in the role of
innocent naughty boy but still less did he like having to borrow
yet again.

Then, by God! The pony! In his secret heart he was aware
that he couldn’t manage it. The pony was vicious. He had
made a mess of Prentice’s syce. Put him on his back for a week,
they said. ‘Oh, what the hell!’ he thought. ‘Damnation to you,
Major Prentice!’ And he drained his glass.

The regimental doctor sitting opposite watched him guardedly.
He always felt out of place in the elegant company of
Bateman’s Horse. He tried not to, but could not help contrasting
the splendour of their grey and silver mess dress with his
own Indian Medical Service dark blue. He was not, in fact,
thinking about Dolly Prentice. He was thinking about Prentice.
He remembered (would he ever forget?) the public
shame that had followed his first greeting at the hands of
Major Prentice.

‘Tell me, doctor,’ he had said, ‘– we are all so eager to know
– from what barrow in Petticoat Lane did you buy those boots?’

It was true that his boots did not come from a fashionable
boot-maker. They had come from a saddler in Maidstone and
they had looked good enough when he had first tried them
on. He was painfully aware that, by comparison with the
officers of Bateman’s Horse, the ‘Bengal Greys’, he lacked the
skintight precision supplied by Lobb of St James’s, the skintight
precision which forbade anything more substantial
inside than a cut-down ladies’ silk stocking.

His thoughts turned to Dolly. Dolly with her large eyes
and her ready sympathy. How could she bear life with that
devil? How could she put up with him close to her? And a
vision of Dolly in the arms of Giles Prentice rose, not for the
first time, to trouble him. He imagined the heat of an Indian
night. He imagined the close confines of a mosquito net. He
tried but did not succeed in keeping at bay the vision of
Prentice’s slim brown hands exploring the surface anatomy
which his fervid imagination and medical experience conjured
up. Too easily.

The senior officer present, Major Harry, looked up and
down the table. Over-bright eyes, mottled faces, desultory
and slurred speech – there was no doubt about it, when Prentice
was away conversation ebbed and the drink flowed to fill the
gaps. And Prentice was away. He had gone to Calcutta for an
interview for promotion to the senior branch. ‘But why Giles?
Why not me?’ There could only be one of them this time and
that one was Prentice. This had been the moment when he
might have broken through and God knew when there might
be another one.

His career really needed the step. He needed the money.
Very soon there would be children to be sent home to school
in England. Already his wife was complaining
and he was sick of the endless litany – ‘Nothing to wear . . . only one carriage
horse . . . when can we buy our own furniture?’ He had desperately
needed this step and now Prentice had it. Pretentious
Prentice!

Dickie Templar likewise surveyed the company. On attachment
and waiting to join a Gurkha regiment on the north-west
frontier, he was glad that he was not to be gazetted into
Bateman’s Horse. He felt that though they had a glowing past
(they had been golden heroes of the Mutiny) they had for too
long rested on their laurels and their promotion prospects
were not good. And the officers – they bored him. Further
than that, they even repelled him. Sick of their company, he
rose from the table and made his way to the ghulskhana
where, with difficulty, unbuttoning the flap of his tight mess
trousers, he stood for a moment aiming largely by memory
in the darkness.

It was a fetid little enclosure and with his spare hand he
pushed open the window through which instantly there
came a murmur of unfamiliar sound. An unfamiliar
sound in a crescendo and – there – what was that? A shot. And
another shot. Buttoning himself up, he stood on tiptoe and
gazed out of the window. There was a yellow leaping flame
beginning to spring from one of the bungalows, about half a
mile away, he judged. A fire? Yes, there was a fire and now
there was a smell of smoke. A fire in the lines? Probably nothing.
No one else seemed aware of it as he hurried back to the
dining-room.

‘There’s a fire!’ he said. And then again, ‘There’s a fire in
the lines!’
 

In line abreast, the five Greys officers cantered on down
towards the disturbance. They clattered into the compound
and surveyed with dismay the ruin of Prentice’s house. And
here they were challenged by a figure in a scarlet mess
jacket, his white shirt front blackened. The Braganza Lamb
in silver thread on his lapel identified the Queen’s duty
officer. Four British soldiers, presumably
the Queen’s fire picket, were hauling on the handle of the fire engine and
two more were directing a jet of water into the ruin. Others,
faces bound in cloth, made useless attempts to approach.
Riflemen stood by.

‘What the hell’s been going on here?’ said Major Harry.

‘Disaster! Total disaster!’ came the reply. ‘We did our best
but we were too late. Bloody fire engine! About as much good
as a water pistol! We organised a bucket chain but we were too
few and too late.’

‘Too late to save the bungalow?’

‘To hell with the bungalow! Too late to save Dolly and
Midge Prentice.’

‘But they’re in Calcutta with Giles! He always takes them
with him!’

‘Not this time, he didn’t! It’s Midge’s birthday tomorrow
– Dolly stayed at home with her for her party. Good God! My
girls were going!’ He wiped a blackened and bleeding hand
across his face. ‘My girls were to be there,’ he said again. ‘No,
there’s no sign of Midge or her mother . . . must be still in
there . . . what’s left of the poor devils . . . The minute this lot
cools down enough to get men in we’ll look for the bodies.
Jesus! And Prentice away! I say – a disaster!’

‘But who the hell . . .?’

‘Dacoits . . . we think it was dacoits. Doped up, no doubt –
drugged-up courage. In a mood to stop at nothing. It happens.
Prentice had been routing them out of village after
village and they came for him. Didn’t know he was away, I suppose
. . . Or perhaps they knew only too well! They’ve chased
all the servants off or they’ve fled. No sign of them anyway.
Come crawling back in the morning I dare say and then we’ll
find out more.’

Dickie Templar had heard enough. He turned aside and
blundered into the darkness to hide his distress. He stopped
dead. He had heard a faint cry.

From a stack of tall flowerpots there emerged a ghostlike
figure: Midge Prentice, white face a mask of terror, her
bunched nightie gripped convulsively in a small hot hand.
Dickie fell on his knees and gathered her in his arms, sobbing,
kissing her face and holding her to him, murmuring childish
endearments. ‘You got out!’ he said at last. ‘You got out!’ And
then, ‘Where’s Mummy?’

For reply, the child pointed dumbly to the smouldering
ruin of the house.
 

Chapter Two
Calcutta 1922

Commander Joseph Sandilands of the Metropolitan Police
was delighted to be going home. Delighted that his six
months’ secondment from the Met to the Bengal Police
should, at last, be at an end.

He’d had enough India. He’d had enough heat. He’d had
enough smells.

Though no stranger to the midden that was the East End
of London he’d not, by a long way, been able to accept the
poverty that surrounded him. And he still resented the social
formalities of Calcutta. As a London policeman, his social
status had been, at the least, equivocal in the precedent-conscious
atmosphere of the capital of Bengal. He had
counted the days until he could pack, say his farewells and
go, but even that pleasure was denied him; inevitably, the
bearer who had been assigned to him had done his packing
for him. But, by whatever means, it was at last done and
tomorrow he’d be gone.

For the last time – he sincerely hoped it was the last time –
he made his way into the office that had been allocated to
him. For the last time he cursed the electric fan that didn’t
work. For the last time he was embarrassed
by the patient presence of the punkha-wallah manipulating the sweeping fan that
disturbed but did not disperse the heavy air. There was,
however, a neat envelope lying on his desk. Stamped across
the flap were the words: ‘The Office of the Governor’.

With anxious hand he tore open the envelope and read:

Dear Sandilands,
I hope you can make it convenient to call in and see
me this morning. Something has cropped up which we
should discuss. I have sent a rickshaw.
Yours sincerely,

And an indecipherable signature followed with the words
‘Sir George Jardine, Acting Governor of Bengal’.

Joe didn’t like the sound of this. Could he pretend he’d
never received it and just leave? No, they’d catch him in the
act and what could be more embarrassing than being brought
back from the docks under police escort? Better not chance
it! He looked angrily out of the window and there were,
indeed, two liveried rickshaw men waiting to deliver him to
the Governor. He’d met George Jardine on one or two formal
occasions during his secondment and formed a good impression
of the distinguished old pro-consul who had come out of
retirement to bridge the gap between two incumbents.

The appointment seemed to be a formal one and he
paused in the vestibule to check his appearance. ‘God! You
look tired, Sandilands,’ he muttered at his reflection.
He still half expected to see the eager youth who had set off for the
war with the Scots Fusiliers but, though the hair was still black
and plentiful, after four years in France and four years with
the police his expression was watchful now and cynical. An old
wound on his forehead – badly stitched – had pulled up the
corner of one eyebrow so that, even in repose, his face looked
perpetually enquiring. Six months of Indian sun appeared to
have bleached his grey eyes as it had darkened his skin. But at
least in India everything he possessed was polished without
any word from him. He adjusted his black Sam Browne belt
shining like glass, his silver rank badges and his medal ribbons,
the blue of the police medal almost edged out by the red
and blue DSO and his three war medals. He’d do.

The rickshaw set off without a word, the rickshaw men trotting
steadily ahead through the heavy press of traffic. Seeing
the Governor’s livery, people made way for him. ‘Another six
months,’ he thought, ‘and I believe I could get used to this.
It’s certainly time I was home!’

‘Morning, Sandilands,’ said the Governor, as though greeting
an old friend. ‘Not too early for a peg, I hope? Whisky-soda?’

‘Yes,’ thought Joe, ‘far too early but what can one do?’

He watched as Jardine poured out two generous glasses.

‘I have your chit, sir,’ he said, hoping he didn’t sound as
resentful as he felt.

‘Yes, well . . .’ the Governor began. ‘Funny business. I’ve
wired your chaps in London, and hope you don’t mind my
having done so, over your head, as you might say. But – your
lecture the other night – I was very impressed . . . Everybody
was. Opened our eyes to a lot of things! Don’t want to cut down
our chaps here – they do a wonderful job – but they’re up to
their ears and it has come to me that maybe we need a little bit
extra. May be nothing in it, of course. Once the women start
gossiping you never know quite where it’s going to end and . . .’
He paused and sipped his drink. ‘Do help yourself. But the fact
is that I telegraphed your chief to ask if we could borrow you
for a bit longer. Everyone here would be delighted – but the
problem isn’t here, it’s in a place called Panikhat about fifty
miles south of here. It’s on the railway. Not a bad journey and
they’ll put you up in splendour and state, no doubt. Pretty
good fellows down there. It’s a civil and military station.’

Joe Sandilands was hardly listening. ‘I could have been sailing
down the Hooghly River by now! Why the hell didn’t I go
last night?’

The Governor resumed, ‘I don’t suppose this is what you
wanted for a moment but if you’ll take this on it couldn’t do
your career any harm, I think. As I say, there are some very good
fellows down there – Bateman’s Horse. We call them the Bengal
Greys – grey horses – the Indian equivalent of the Scots Greys,
don’t you know . . . But I won’t waste any more time chatting.’

He held up a letter by its corner. ‘It’s all here but there’s
somebody I would like you to meet.’ He seemed for a moment
reluctant to come to the point, finally concluding, ‘It’s my
niece, you see. She’s about the place somewhere . . . Her husband
is the Collector of Panikhat and they’re stationed down
there. Between you and me and strictly between you and me
– he’s a peaceful sort of chap . . . anything for a quiet life. Not
much go about him. Perhaps Nancy’s only taken this up
because she was bored. But, I don’t know – they seem happy
enough together. Anyway, Nancy’s as bright as a new rupee
and ah! Nancy, my dear, there you are! This is Commander
Sandilands. Sandilands, my niece, Nancy Drummond.’

For the first time since this terrible news broke for Joe, he
woke to the possibility that there might be compensations
in this so unwelcome interruption to his life. Mention
of the Collector’s wife had instantly produced a vision of Anglo-Indian
respectability at its most oppressive but the figure before him
was quite a surprise.

For one thing, she was younger by twenty years than he had
been expecting and for another, she was smartly – even fashionably
– dressed. White silk blouse, well-cut jodhpurs, broad-brimmed
hat in one hand, fly whisk in the other and an
enquiring – if slightly suspicious – face. He tried not to be too
obviously appraising her. He was aware that she was fairly obviously
appraising him. This could just be rather fun.

‘Now, Nancy,’ said the Governor, ‘sit down and tell Sandilands
what you told me. I’ve warned him that there may be
nothing whatever in it but you’ve interested
me at least and we’ll do our best to interest him.’

Nancy sat down in a chair opposite Joe and looked at him
seriously and for a long time before speaking. Now she was
closer he saw that the pretty face was pale and strained. She
made no attempt at a smile but went straight into her narrative.
Her voice was low and clear, her tone urgent. She’d obviously
prepared and prepared again what she was going to say.

‘A week ago a ghastly thing happened on the station. Peggy
Somersham, the wife of William Somersham, Captain in the
Greys, was found dead in her bath with her wrists cut. Of
course, everybody said “Suicide” but, really, there was absolutely
no reason. They weren’t very long married. Quite a
difference in age – that’s often the way in India – people wait
to get hitched till their career is established and an officer
does not in fact qualify for a marriage allowance until he is
thirty. One can’t always tell, of course, but they seemed not
only happy, but very happy together. People often said – “Ideal
marriage”.

‘I know that funny things happen in India but just the facts
by themselves, to my mind at any rate, were suspicious
and Bulstrode, the Police Superintendent, didn’t seem able to
explain anything to anyone’s satisfaction. We all thought for
one moment he was about to take the easy way out and arrest
poor Billy Somersham . . .’

‘Now Nancy,’ said the Governor, ‘tell it straight.’

‘Sorry, Uncle! And look here . . .’ She took an envelope
from her uncle’s desk, slid out two photographs and handed
them to Joe.

His mouth tightened with distaste.

‘Who took these?’

‘Well, actually, I did . . .’

‘My niece served as a nurse on the Western Front for three
years,’ said the Governor and sat back, apologetic but happy
with this explanation.

‘Mr Sandilands, sadly, a bathful of blood in my experience
is nothing. And I have first-hand knowledge of wounds. Even
cut wrists . . .’ She paused, disturbed momentarily by her
memories. ‘I suppose you think it rather shocking that I
should be able to stand there in front of this appalling scene
and take photographs?’

Not wishing to stop the flow of her story Joe merely nodded.
He did find it shocking but realised that a conventional
denial would not deceive this determined woman. His professional
curiosity was eager for details of how she had managed
under those difficult circumstances to take photographs of such
clarity but he remained silent and looked at her with
what he hoped was a suitable blend of sympathy and
encouragement.

‘Yes, well, I was pretty much shocked myself. She was my
friend, Mr Sandilands, and this was not easily done. But this is
the hot season. There was little else I could do to preserve the
scene of the death as it was. Bulstrode was giving orders for the
body to be taken away and buried at once and he authorised
the khitmutgar to arrange for the bathroom to be cleaned up.
I’m afraid I stepped in and insisted that Andrew – that’s my
husband, the Collector – called him off. Of course the body
had to be buried, after a quick post-mortem done by the station
doctor, but we managed to get the servants to leave as
much as possible of the bathroom untouched. I don’t want to
interfere, of course . . .’ (The Governor smiled ironically.) ‘. . .
but a word with the doctor mightn’t be out of place. His name
is Halloran. I don’t know him very well. Irish. A lot of army
doctors are. He seems nice enough.’

‘You preserved the scene of crime – if crime it was – Mrs
Drummond, and with the skill, apparently, of a seasoned
officer of the Met. But I’m wondering why it should have
occurred to you to take these steps . . .?’

‘My uncle had spoken about you and the work you were
doing here in Calcutta when I was last here some weeks ago. I
popped into one of your lectures and I was very impressed
with what you had to say. I tried to wangle a meeting there and
then but you were besieged by a phalanx of earnest young
Bengali Police Force officers and I had to drift away. But then,
when this happened, I rang Uncle at once and he made a few
telephone calls, worked his magic and here we are.’

She smiled for the first time since they had met and her
face lit up with mischief. ‘And I don’t suppose you’re at all
pleased!’

Joe smiled back. He had an idea that there was not much
he would be able to conceal from the Collector’s wife.

‘It’s difficult to make out but if you will look at the second
photograph . . .’ she said, drawing his attention back to the
horror he still held in his hand.

Joe concentrated on the close-up of the dead girl’s wrists
and saw at once where she was leading but he let her go on.

‘You see it, don’t you? She couldn’t have done that herself,
don’t you agree?’

Joe nodded and she went on, ‘But that’s not all of it, nor
perhaps even the worst of it, Commander. After Peggy’s death
the gossip started. I’ve only been on the station for three years
and I hadn’t heard the stories . . . in any case, I think people
thought it was all over . . . like a nightmare. It stops and you
lull yourself into thinking it’s never going to happen again.
And then it does. And it’s worse than before.

‘Everyone who had been there since before the war was
eager to tell me the stories.’ She leaned forward in her chair
to emphasise her point. ‘Mr Sandilands, every year before the
war and going back to 1910, the wife of a Greys officer has
been killed. In March.

‘The first to die was Mrs Major Prentice – Dorothy. In a fire.
Tragic, of course, but no one paid all that much attention as
it was quite clearly due to an act of dacoity – banditry. The
forests and some of the villages too used to be infested with
bandits before the war. They are still to be found but it’s nothing
like so bad as it was thanks to Prentice and others. The
following March in 1911, Joan Carmichael, the wife of Colonel
Carmichael, was fatally bitten by a snake. And there’s nothing
strange about that in India, you’re going to say – but in this
case there was an oddity . . . The next March, Sheila Forbes
fell over a precipice while out riding and in 1913 Alicia Simms-
Warburton was drowned.’

‘And then came the war.’

‘Yes. People were moved around. The series was broken
and – goodness knows! – there were enough deaths to worry
about in the next few years . . . people forgot. But this fifth
death revived memories. It began to be said that marrying an
officer in the Greys was a high-risk occupation! Gossip and
speculation are meat and drink to officers’ wives and they live
in a very restricted circle. They can and do talk each other into
a high state of panic about the slightest thing – you can imagine
what this is doing to their nerves! One of the wives is talking,
quite seriously I believe, about returning to England. And
some of the younger ones are running a sweep-stake on which
one of them is to be the next victim! Just a piece of bravado
but I think it’s a sign that the tension is becoming unbearable.
Commander, we need you to come to Panikhat and get to the
bottom of this. Either we investigate the whole thing, decide
there’s no foundation for any of these wild theories and reassure
the ladies or . . .’ She paused for a moment and her expression
grew grim,‘. . . or we find the . . . the . . . bastard –
sorry, Uncle! – who’s killed my friend and make absolutely
sure he’s in no position ever to do it again!’