The holidays are upon Magnolia Cove and Pepper has lots of plans. Number one, make Grumpy a girlfriend. Number two, capture Santa Claus. Wait--number two is definitely not on the list. But when a man falls from a sleigh, no one doubts that he's Saint Nick. Well, no one but Pepper, that is. Because the thing is, she doesn't believe in Santa Claus.
As if that wasn't bad enough, Saint Nick has amnesia. It's up to the folks in Magnolia Cove to restore his memory and save Christmas. But can they? And will Pepper discover that there is a Santa Claus after all, or will she be a Scrooge?