A heartrending story of loss, grief, and legacy that asks how much we can ever really know the ones we love—and what it means to love them, and ourselves, anyway. Perfect for fans of Nina LaCour and Adam Silvera.
Jonny has always idolized his sister, Carmel. She is the person he relies on for guidance, insight, and pretty much everything else.
Trish has always followed her father's lead. As a senator from Pennsylvania, he devotes his life to public service, and Trish is right there beside him, determined to make the world a better place.
But when the senator's plane crashes in Jonny’s backyard—killing everyone on board and taking Carmel's life as well—Jonny's and Trish's worlds are shattered in an instant.
As they navigate their own separate pain, Jonny and Trish each discover things about the people they thought they'd known best. And they find themselves wondering: Had they ever truly known the people they’d looked up to—and do they truly know themselves now that their loved ones are gone? Looking for answers, they turn toward each other for support, solace, and maybe something more.
In this powerful novel, award-winning author Isaac Blum explores what it means to grieve, to love, and to find yourself anew in the wreckage of personal tragedy. With his signature wit and compassion, he shares a story with one universal truth: that while grief may shape our paths, it doesn't have to dictate our future.
Release date:
November 17, 2026
Publisher:
Philomel Books
Print pages:
320
* BingeBooks earns revenue from qualifying purchases as an Amazon Associate as well as from other retail partners.
That one June day means so many different things to me now. It’s hard to separate them and describe them individually, even to myself. It’s like this giant tangle of yarn I’ve been picking at ever since.
But on the day itself, it meant one simple thing: It was the first day of summer.
School had just finished the day before, and as I stood in the front hall, looking down the street, I could see the summer stretched out in front of me, full of freedom and possibility.
“Why are you here?” my brother, David, demanded. “To nag me?”
He wasn’t talking to me. He was talking to our sister, Carmel. He only used that tone with her.
They were standing behind me in the living room, and I could see them reflected in the glass of the window: David’s hands in the pockets of his athletic shorts, Carmel’s on the hips of her baggy jeans.
“Guys say it’s nagging any time they’re asked to do anything,” she said. “Dad does it to Mom.”
“So that’s a yes?”
“Bus the dishes before you leave for the game. There are cups everywhere in here. It’ll take you two minutes. You know Mom worries about getting those little circles on the furniture.”
“I don’t think she’s too worried about it right now,” David said. He pulled his phone out of his pocket, poked at it, and turned it around so Carmel could see it. “She’s on the beach with a drink. She’s relaxing, something you should try for—”
“You follow Mom on Instagram?”
“The Family app doesn’t work in the other direction. Seems only fair.”
“Weird. Does she dispense parenting advice on there? ‘Hot tip: Go across the world for a week and leave your vain, self-obsessed son in charge.’ ”
“I can’t stand being in the same house as you,” David said.
“No problem. I’m going outside.”
Carmel disappeared into the backyard. David joined me at the window and slapped me on the back. “Go get changed,” he said. “You can’t go dressed like that. It’s a baseball game, not a bar mitzvah.”
I looked down at my khakis. I guess it was a little warm out for pants.
“I don’t know if I’m going with you,” I said.
David had invited me to a Phillies game with him. He said he knew a guy at the stadium who would serve us beer. With our parents out of town, they wouldn’t know if we came home drunk. He’d invited along two girls.
“The girls . . .” I said. “They’re your age. Older.” David had just finished his junior year, and I’d just finished my freshman one.
“Don’t worry about that,” he said with a dismissive wave of his hand. “It’s summer.”
“What’s the season got to do with—”
“The summer doesn’t count, Jon. An older girl can hook up with you, and it’ll be erased in the fall. The summer isn’t real.”
“The summer isn’t real,” I repeated.
I saw the two girls come up the walk. I recognized both of them, but couldn’t put names to faces. They were dressed identically, in short jean shorts and V‑neck Phillies T‑shirts. They matched David: cool, confident, tall.
They did not match me. I was none of those things. Actually, I was tall, but that was a recent development, and I hadn’t gotten used to it yet.
“I’m going to go run it by Carmel,” I said.
“Of course you are. You’re such a virgin, bro.”
I wanted to explain to him that virginity was a binary. You either were or were not. You couldn’t be such a virgin. But I didn’t say that, because I didn’t want to be ridiculed or punched or sat upon. Those weren’t things I said aloud to David. They were things I kept in my head and talked to Carmel about afterward.
I walked into the backyard, across the sloping lawn, to the big tree down by the creek.
The big tree down by the creek sounds really beautiful, but that’s only if you squint so you can’t see the power lines and the floating plastic bags, and if you don’t get too close to the water. In biology class we did a project where we tested the purity of the creek water. It was impure. The creek had a pH that was either way too high or way too low—I can’t remember which.
I found my sister on a towel under the tree with a book, some needles, and a pile of felt. “You’re always lying around the yard like it’s a park,” I said.
“The yard is just a smaller, more private park.”
“The ice cream truck never comes to the yard,” I said.
“Which is fine, because I’m not six years old. There’s ice cream in the freezer.”
I went up to Carmel’s towel, casting my shadow over her.
I was the youngest. Carmel was the middle kid, but somehow she felt like the oldest. “Have a good time, Jon,” she said. She prodded some felt with her needle. The felt was gray. It looked like it was going to be an owl. She made a lot of felt owls.
“I’m staying here with you.”
“No you’re not. You’re not staying here. Let me tell you what will happen if you stay here, so you can picture it. If you stay here with me, you’ll sit right there.” She paused to point to a spot next to her where a tree root poked out of the ground. “You’ll watch David on social media, and you’ll be miserable, and you’ll try to show me the pictures and videos that are tearing you apart with FOMO, and I’ll tell you that I told you so, and you’ll only get more upset. So go to the game. I’ll be right here when you get back, and I’ll be more willing to listen to you complain about David’s schemes, because I won’t have spent the whole afternoon listening to you.”
“David’s schemes?” I said.
“Have you stopped to wonder why he invited you to the game? Do you think it’s because he wants his little brother to tag along with him? He’s using you. That’s what David does. There’s something he wants, and he thinks he can use you to get it. Other people are just chess pieces he can move around his board. You’re just a pawn to him.”
“Which ones are the pawns again? Are they the really cool important pieces that can move any way they want?”
I didn’t think David was using me. Carmel had to be wrong. She’d never been wrong before, but that didn’t mean she couldn’t be wrong this time. So far, the sun had risen every day in the history of the earth. But there would come a day when it didn’t, when it would supernova instead and destroy the solar system. This could be that day, and Carmel could be wrong, and David could want to hang out with his little brother, without ulterior motives.
“I see that you’re skeptical,” Carmel said. “It sucks, because it would be easier for you if you just took my word for it. Now you’ll have to wait for it to play out, see it for yourself, and the disappointment will hit you so much harder.”
I wanted to contradict her, but I had a firm policy of not contradicting Carmel. She didn’t like to be contradicted.
I didn’t know what to say, so I said the thing that was stuck in my head: “The summer isn’t real.”
That felt true to me. Summer had that unreal quality to it, like a kind of exciting purgatory, an in‑between space that didn’t count on life’s ledger, where even impossibilities were possible. In the summer, I could be free and fearless, an explorer of new and exciting things. I could act cool and mature, hanging out with two older girls. David could bring me along because he valued my company.
“The summer isn’t real?” Carmel said. “What does that mean?”
I had no answer to that question.
“Did David say that? That’s the kind of dumb thing David says.”
I both loved and hated how transparent I was to Carmel. It was unnerving when it felt like somebody could read your thoughts. But it was also nice that somebody understood me, and convenient that she understood me before I did.
She set her needle to the side. The felt was definitely going to be an owl. It had an eye now.
Carmel looked up at me for the first time. Her little gold chain—the one with the Jewish star on it—had fallen over her shoulder, so she readjusted it. “I think you wore that shirt at your bar mitzvah,” she said. Carmel was usually serious. Dour, even. But there was a light in her eye now, and a little smile at the corner of her mouth. “You had a blue blazer over it. You were so cute. Your voice kept cracking. And you still had that baby fat in your cheeks. When I’m upset, I go back and watch videos of it. You were so adorable.”
“Weird,” I said. But I didn’t think it was weird. I liked that she did that. “I’m gonna go change.”
I went inside, up to my room. I walked back out to say goodbye two minutes later, wearing my Phillies shirt and matching cap. “Wait,” I said. The heat reminded me: “I’ll grab you an ice cream before I go.”
“I don’t think we actually have any,” Carmel said. “I was just trying to make a point.”
Chapter 2 Trish
At the stadium’s VIP entrance, I was greeted by a handler in a white button-down shirt with a Phillies insignia sewn into it. She wore a little headset with a microphone attached, so when she spoke, I couldn’t tell if she was talking to me or to whoever was on the headset.
When I first got to the door, she was in the middle of a sentence. But then she said, “You must be Trish,” and I knew at least that was meant for me.
It was Clearwell Health Night at the Ballpark, and I was supposed to throw out the first pitch at the baseball game, along with my father. I’d never done this before, but I’d also done it a thousand times. This kind of thing. My dad was one of Pennsylvania’s two senators, and we’d done countless promotions, photo ops, and campaign events together.
I did my best political greeting. Taking the woman’s outstretched hand in both of mine, I smiled at her and said, “Beautiful night for a ball game,” even though I wasn’t sure what the forecast was, and had no idea what conditions were ideal for baseball.
“Did the senator arrive with you?” the woman asked.
He was supposed to have arrived with me. The senator had actually promised me I could chauffeur him. I’d just gotten my license, and I was excited to drive him for the first time. He’d also promised to be back home the night before, so we could have a family dinner for the first time in . . . I wasn’t sure how long.
But he’d texted us about mechanical problems with the plane, so he was going to miss dinner. He was stuck in Pittsburgh. There was an opportunity for an event with first responders in the morning, so he lined up a plane to get him here in time for the game. But my chauffeuring would have to wait until next time.
“He’ll be here soon,” I said.
The woman handed me a pass on a lanyard and rattled off some instructions for the event. Then she led me into the bowels of the stadium, through a series of hallways, into a little waiting space. There were snacks and drinks laid out on tables with red tablecloths. People dressed like my person—button-down shirts and slacks—popped in and out of the room looking eager and purposeful.
“XL for the senator,” my lady said. “I think the medium will work for you.”
On the table next to her there were two baseball jerseys, white with thin vertical red stripes. They were laid out with the front down, the back facing up at us. Both jerseys had MACON written out over the top, the number 2 below.
The woman picked up the smaller one and helped me into it.
I was wearing a V‑neck T‑shirt with my dad’s signature slogan on it: THE ONLY WAY IS FORWARD. I’d cut the neck of the shirt myself, so the Y WAY was missing. But the message was still clear.
I could tell the woman wanted me to button up the jersey over the shirt, but I wasn’t going to. Dad would want to keep the slogan visible.
I checked my phone. I looked over the last text from Mike, one of my dad’s aides. Plane should have him in Philly in time for first pitch.
That was the last update I’d gotten. Nothing from the senator himself. But that wasn’t unusual. That’s why he had guys like Mike.
My minder checked her watch again. “Are you out of school yet?” she asked. “My daughter just finished yesterday.”
“Yeah,” I said. “Same.”
“Big plans for the summer?”
I looked around the room. It was filling up with VIP-looking people, little passes hanging around their necks. A photographer in a red polo had appeared in the corner, and he was snapping photos of me standing with my handler.
“The senator is up for reelection this fall,” I told her, “so I’ll be spending my summer supporting my dad however I can, so he can keep supporting all of us in Washington.”
The woman nodded at me. It was a knowing nod. It was game recognizing game.
Then something must have come to her through her headset, because she put a hand up to her ear and held it there for a moment. “Two minutes,” she said.
I checked my phone. Usually, I would have gotten a message with an update on an ETA. Maybe I didn’t have good service? I was underground, but the screen still showed one bar.
And it was ringing.
He was calling.
I stepped into the hallway and answered. “Where are you?” I asked.
“Hello to you too,” he replied. Or, I think that’s what he said. There was a lot of noise on his end. I shook my phone like that might clear the connection.
“Listen,” he said. “I’m not going to make it in time for the first pitch. I’m really sorry.”
He continued talking, but I held the phone down at my side for a moment to collect myself. I was surprised to find that I felt let down. The night was sponsored by Clearwell, a big partner in my dad’s push to expand healthcare access, and henever missed anything with them. Plus, he’d missed our family dinner and his chauffeured ride to the game. I thought for sure he’d make it so we could watch a little baseball together and support his work—our work—at the same time.
You read about absentee dads who aren’t home enough because they’re cheating on their wife, or they have a crippling gambling addiction and they spend all of their time at the casino—that’s what happened with my friend Mya’s dad. Some dads just work all the time, and they’re traveling around selling . . . whatever people sell. Construction equipment? Life insurance?
But my situation is different. My dad is different. Yeah, he misses a lot of stuff for his work. But his work really matters. There are so few people who can directly improve other people’s lives, who can truly make the world a better place. But he is one of those few.
I could feel eyes on me, people looking out from the VIP room into the hall. I put on my most casual smile and brought the phone back to my ear. “You’ll have to do it without me,” he was saying.
“Yeah,” I said. “It’s okay. No worries. I got it.”
“I need to tell you something,” he was saying.
“Oh, I’m even wearing the new campaign shirt,” I said. “I was waiting for you to see it, but now I guess I’ll just tell you.”
The woman stepped into the hallway from the VIP room. “We need to go to the field,” she said. She reached for my sleeve and started to lead me somewhere, through the VIP room, into another hallway, then another room, then another hallway.
“Huh?” I said, partly to her, partly into the phone.
“I know . . .” he was saying. “I know you’ll make me proud.”
What was he even talking about? It was a ceremonial pitch. How proud could that make anybody? “Dad, I’m going to throw a ball. It’s not a big deal.”
“And I think . . .” he was saying, but he was cutting in and out.
“I’m losing you,” I said.
I could see the light at the end of the tunnel anyway, and I knew I’d need to hang up in a moment.
“I think . . . I think it’s important you know . . .”
“Know what?” I asked.
But now I couldn’t hear him, or any of the call’s background noise. “Know what?” I asked, but I wasn’t even talking into the phone mic now. I had the phone out in front of me, at arm’s length, so I was just asking nobody. The call had ended, but I didn’t know if it had gotten cut off on his end, because service on planes could be unreliable, or if it had gotten cut off on my end, because service in tunnels could also be unreliable. If there was something important he needed to tell me, he should have told me while he wasn’t on a plane and I wasn’t in a tunnel.
Suddenly, I wasn’t in a tunnel. Suddenly, I was in the brightest place in the world.
Because I’ve gone back and looked, I know I stepped out on the field at 6:04 p.m. The sun was still bright—there wasn’t a cloud in the sky—but the stadium lights were also on, and I was blinded for a moment. Maybe that’s why I don’t remember the walk to the pitcher’s mound very well.
I noticed I was there when my feet were on a slope. I was on the dirt, off the infield grass. I had a baseball in my right hand, its seams across my fingers.
I scanned the crowd. Some people were still filtering in, but it was pretty full. I was struck by how the smell on the field was so . . . field-like. I would have expected it to be overpowered by the smell of hot dogs and popcorn, or sunscreen and body odor. But even with the huge stadium rising up around me, if I closed my eyes, I could tell myself I was just a girl on a field.
But I couldn’t do that. There was a guy standing next to me with a camera, and the shot was live on the jumbotron.
An announcer’s voice exploded out of the speakers. “Throwing out the first pitch of today’s game,” he began, and his voice kept rising in excitement as he continued, “brought to us by Clearwell Health, please welcome Pennsylvania senator Russell Macon, and his daughter, Patricia.”
When she’d explained the run of show, the woman had told me to pause and wave. So with the baseball in my right hand, I smiled directly into the camera and waved with my left. The crowd cheered politely. Not a home run cheer, but a nice round of applause.
Out of the corner of my eye, I could see myself smiling and waving on screen. Under my face it said, “Senator Macon and Patricia.”
But neither of those people were there. Senator Macon was still on the plane. He hadn’t called me back to tell me whatever it was he wanted to tell me. And there were probably Patricias in the stadium, but the girl on the mound was not one of them. My name is just Trish.
I felt my phone buzz in the back pocket of my shorts, and I desperately wanted to check it. Was he calling me back? Now would be the time he would call back.
My minder signaled that it was pitch time, and I saw that the mascot was crouched behind the plate with an oversize glove, waiting.
When you watch it back, it appears that I’m concentrating really hard. But that was just the look I put on my face. My mind was all over the place, wondering about the timing of the vibration in my pocket, whose fault it was that the Phillies PR people had the name wrong on the jumbotron chyron, and whether I’d get to watch some of the game with my dad.
I know what the video shows, but I swear, even though I never played formal baseball, I could throw the ball. I was just preoccupied. Despite all of my practice keeping my cool in this kind of situation, I’d let myself slip just the tiniest bit. And when I swung my right arm forward, I forgot to let go.
When it happened, I wasn’t even watching the ball. I didn’t realize I’d thrown it straight into the ground until the crowd started booing. The boos cascaded down, and I did the only thing I knew how to do: I kept the smile plastered on my face. I waved my hand and smiled into the camera, just like I’d been taught. I accepted a fierce hug from the mascot, which wasn’t too gross if you try to forget that he’s a very sweaty grown man in a fur suit.
“Once again, put your hands together for Patricia,” the announcer called.
The crowd answered his call with another round of boos.
By the time I got back into the tunnel, my phone was exploding, and I had no idea what the original vibration had been, the one I’d felt on the mound.
“Thanks so much, Trish,” my minder said. “It’s so hard when you only have the one try. You were such a good sport. I can take you up to the Hall of Fame club now. Food, drinks, and a great view of the game. I’ll ask her.”
That last one must have been for the person on the other end of the headset, because the lady touched me on the arm, and asked, “Do you know if the senator will be coming to the game? I want to make sure we have somebody to greet him.”
I don’t think I replied.
I was looking at my phone. My friends were reacting to my pitch on Snapchat. It was mostly good-natured.
OMG I’m sorry Trish, Mya said.
You’d fit right in on the team, Jaxon said, implying that the Phillies were also bad at pitching.
Evie said, They should have let you sing the national anthem instead.
I also had texts in the group chat with my mom, Mike, and my dad’s other longtime aide, Sandy.
Sandy’s had come in first. Have you spoken to him? it asked.
Mike’s said, Has he called you?
Whatever my dad wanted to tell me, was it something they were all coordinating, some kind of big campaign announcement?
Yeah, I sent to them. He told me he had something important he wanted to say, but we got cut off.
What time was that? Sandy asked.
I looked back through my call log and gave her the time of the initial conversation and then his call back to me, the one I’d felt in my pocket on the pitcher’s mound.
That’s right about when I missed his call, my mom said. She was at a dinner with some potential donors.
Now I called Dad back. I wanted to know if he’d seen the video. I knew I’d have trouble living my first pitch down, but I also knew that he and I would enjoy watching it together, and he’d say something like, “Well, these are the sacrifices we make for the work.” And that would be enough to make the whole thing worth it.
But my call went straight to voicemail. I tried again with the same result.
They’re taking me to some seating area, I told the group. Just update me on his arrival I guess.
The woman showed me into a little suite with a buffet of food in chafing dishes and big glass windows that looked out over the field. A Phillies pitcher threw a pitch. It went much farther and faster than mine had, and the crowd obliged it with a cheer.
Before I heard again from my mom, and from Mike and Sandy, and from the Philadelphia and Washington offices, I watched a couple innings of baseball in blissful ignorance. I mean, I was bored out of my mind, obviously, but it was a pleasant boredom.
It’s funny what you do and don’t remember. I don’t remember what team the Phillies were playing. I do remember that the cheese sauce for the nachos was surprisingly spicy. I don’t remember who won the game. I do remember seeing Jonny Miller on the jumbotron, and not just because of . . . you know. I really think it’s because it felt like the day had come full circle, and there was some kind of hidden lesson: that anybody—even people who aren’t related to senators—can end up in the spotlight sometimes.
Chapter 3 Jonny
We got to our section a few minutes before the game: me, David, and the two girls. The girls were Gen Park and Izzy Silver. Gen was tall and beautiful. Izzy was tall and freckled. I thought she was pretty enough. But I found most girls pretty. David thought it was important to rank the attractiveness of girls, which I didn’t understand. I didn’t see why we couldn’t come to a harmonious consensus that girls were basically all beautiful, blessed with a wide variety of outstanding physical features.
David led Gen up to the barrier that separated our seating section from the field. “Here,” he said, handing me his phone. “You get us, and then we’ll get you.”
He’d split us into pairs, established that the “us” was him and Gen, and the “you” was me and Izzy. I did as I was told and snapped some pictures of David standing tall and impassive with a smiling Gen, her hand on his chest.
Then David insisted on taking a picture of me and Izzy. Izzy and I stood with a solid foot of space between us, and she was so impatient for it to be over that in the photo she’s a little blurry, because she’s already taking a step forward, away from the field, away from me.
Izzy led us up the stairs toward our row. As I walked, I texted Carmel.
The scheme is that I’m the other guy in a two-man, a kind of fourth wheel.
She replied, Obviously.
It wasn’t obvious to me.
Obviously, she repeated.
Smartass.
Bro, she responded, I’m SO smart.
The first pitch was weird, because they announced both the senator and his daughter, but then it was only Trish on the mound. She didn’t look upset about it. She looked just as happy as I would have been to throw out the first pitch in front of a packed house.
“Yo,” David said. “That’s Trish Macon. She’s the most famous person I’ve heard of.”
I looked at Izzy, because I needed somebody else to acknowledge how nonsensical that statement was. But Izzy wasn’t looking at me. She and David were looking at Gen, who was talking about how she knew Trish, how they used to do dance together, and how Trish still went to Gen for dance tips.
You’ll never believe what David just said, I texted Carmel.
I’ll definitely believe it.
I was trying to remember exactly how he’d put it, so I could transcribe it for Carmel, but I looked up in time to see Trish’s first pitch.
I don’t think I would have spiked the ball like Trish did, but it’s hard to know. It’s hard to get anything right the first time around.
I felt bad for Trish. Izzy put a hand over her mouth in shock. David and Gen cackled in laughter. But at least they didn’t boo like the people around us.
Somehow Trish wasn’t fazed by the boos, and she smiled and waved as she walked off the field.
I took a picture of the jumbotron with Trish on it, and I sent it to Carmel. What’s she like? I asked.
I have no idea, Carmel said.
What do you mean? She’s “the most famous person David’s ever heard of.”
To be clear, she wrote, I DO believe David said that.
Okay. So?
I told you, she responded. I don’t know her.
I didn’t get it. Carmel d
We hope you are enjoying the book so far. To continue reading...