Murder on Cape Cod

Book 1: Cozy Capers Book Group Mystery

by Maddie Day

Genres: Amateur Sleuth; Female Sleuths; Culinary Cozy Mysteries

Synopsis

A Cape Cod shop owner and her book club must find a crafty killer in this charming new series from the Agatha-nominated author of the Country Store Mystery series.

Summer is busy season for Mackenzie "Mac" Almeida's bicycle shop, nestled in the quaint, seaside hamlet of Westham, Massachusetts. She's expecting an influx of tourists at Mac's Bikes; instead she discovers the body of Jake Lacey. Mac can't imagine anyone stabbing the down-on-his-luck handyman. However, the authorities seem to think Mac is a strong suspect after she was spotted arguing with Jake just hours before his death. Mac knows she didn't do it, but she does recognize the weapon — her brother Derrick's fishing knife.

Mac's only experience with murder investigations is limited to the cozy mysteries she reads with her local book group, the Cozy Capers. So to clear her name — and maybe her brother's too — Mac will have to summon help from her Cozy Capers coinvestigators and a library's worth of detectives' tips and tricks. For a small town, Westham is teeming with possible killers, and this is one mystery where Mac is hoping for anything but a surprise ending . . .

Release date: December 31, 2019

Publisher: Kensington Books

Print pages: 304

Sample

It’s the little signs that end up meaning something. The fog. One man’s odd restlessness. Another person’s new confidence. The signs we ignore at our peril.

The weekly meeting of the Cozy Capers book group was winding down in my brother’s lighthouse perched on a promontory in Cape Cod’s hamlet of Westham. Gin Malloy, owner of Salty Taffy’s candy store, lifted her wine glass. “Here’s to a super-charged summer season.”

“I’ll drink to that.” I, Mackenzie Almeida, matched my friend’s gesture. I hoped the summer wouldn’t be too rainy. I was lucky enough to own Mac’s Bikes, a bike rental and repair shop, and we did a booming tourist business as long as the weather stayed fair. We shopkeepers depended on the three-month surge of vacationers for a large chunk of our income.

Tonight, at a little after eight, the lighthouse’s arched windows stood open to the sea air, which blew in the damp scents of early June. The round rooms looked out onto the Atlantic Ocean, or would have if it weren’t too foggy to see the water. Derrick Searle, my half-brother, hadn’t contributed much to the cozy mystery discussion, instead drumming his fingers with a quick nervous movement, gazing out the window into the pea soup. Earlier he’d left the door to the lighthouse unlocked and had tacked up a note telling us to come in and start without him. He’d arrived out of breath after everyone else and without explanation, which was unfortunately typical of him.

Now he puttered around, picking up wine glasses and plates holding remnants of this week’s treat. The members of the group took turns making a dish mentioned in the book under discussion. This week the town clerk had made a couple of killer pizzas for us to share, since Sherry Harris’s I Know What You Bid Last Summer featured an Italian restaurant where Sarah Winston, the garage-sale-maven protagonist, often ate.

I stood to help Derrick but he waved me away.

“I’ll do it, sis,” he said in a gruff tone. He was the private lighthouse’s caretaker and I knew he liked to keep the place tidy, a trait we shared.

The group, ten strong tonight, exchanged farewells and filed down the circular staircase.

“What are we reading for next week?” I asked.

“Cracked to Death, remember?” Gin replied.

“That’s right.” It was the third book in Cheryl Hollon’s Webb’s Glass Shop Mysteries. The group had decided to begin this season with a book set in June—thus starting with last week’s I know What You Bid Last Summer—and then move ahead a month every week, so we’d go through an entire year by the end of August. Cracked was described as taking place during the dog days of summer. Our group, which read exclusively cozy mysteries, had contacted the author to make sure that meant July. She’d assured us it did.

“See you in the morning, Gin,” I called, and waved to the rest, who headed for their cars. Me, I began my short walk home along the biking-walking trail that paralleled the coast. My shop was successful in part because of these paved trails that ran up and down the Cape from Provincetown to Woods Hole. I tried to hurry, smiling to myself because my boyfriend was meeting me at home. Tonight, though, the trail between the lighthouse and my tiny house behind the bike shop was almost unnavigable. It wasn’t long past sunset but the fog was a wall of mist around me. I could barely see where I was going, and I felt my already curly hair gain a new layer of frizz.

I hoped all this damp didn’t seep through my roof. I’d called out Jake Lacey, a down-on-his-luck handyman, about his shoddy repair job earlier. I volunteered serving dinner on Tuesdays in the late afternoon at Our Neighbor’s Table, a food pantry and soup kitchen where Jake was a regular customer.

“Got my check?” he’d asked today as he handed me his plate.

“I’m sorry, Jake, but you did a terrible job on my roof.” It was true. I’d hired him to replace some of the shingles on my micro-house after they’d blown off in a storm. He’d left gaps, some of the replacement shingles were poorly nailed on, and he hadn’t even cleaned up the scraps and debris when he left. I gave him my sternest look. “I’ll pay you after you’ve fixed the shingles and not before.”

The woman behind him in line had raised her eyebrows at my criticism but didn’t say anything. Norland Gifford, the volunteer on my right, who was our newly retired Westham police chief, cleared his throat. I guess I should have saved my comment for a more private setting.

Except Jake hadn’t gotten his back up like he had in the past when anyone criticized him. Instead he’d lifted his pointed chin and waggled his head, wearing a smug expression on his worn face.

“I ain’t gonna even need your money soon, Mac. You wait and see.”

I’d peered at him for a second, having no idea what he meant. “Did you get full-time work?” He was known around town for not being able to hold down a job, which was the reason he was here getting free food, of course.

“Nah. This is better than no stinking job. It’s good, wicked good.” He’d grabbed the plate of pasta and sauce I’d dished up and moved down to the salad section.

“That’s great,” I’d called after him. There went my chance at a decent repair job from Jake. I guess I’d have to find somebody else since I wasn’t going to do it myself. I could tune up a bicycle like nobody’s business, but when it came to hammers and nails, I was all thumbs–and usually both of them got a good self-delivered whack within minutes of attempting anything in the field of carpentry.

Now I found the turn from the bike trail to the pathway that cut up to Main Street. Near the end of the path a hedge of scrubby coastal Rosa Rugosa separated the walkway from my postage stamp of a yard. The fragrant scent from the just-blooming native shrub mixed with the salt air and reminded me of my childhood here on the Cape. I slowed as I rounded a bend. I was scanning through the mist for the opening that would let me through the wall of roses when I tripped.

The obstacle in my path, oddly both soft and solid, was a sizable one. I yelled, arms windmilling like in a vintage cartoon. The air gave me nothing to grab hold of and I landed on my hands and elbows. I glanced down and back to see my knees resting on . . . Jake.

“Gah!” I shrieked and scrambled forward off of him. I crouched in place, my heart beating like the timpani in the Cape Symphony. Jake lay on his front with his head half-turned toward me, lips pulled back in a grimace, eyes unblinking.

“Jake!” I called. “Jake, are you all right?”

He didn’t respond. I inched closer and couldn’t detect any signs of breathing. I touched his temple but I didn’t feel a pulse under his too-cool skin. His skinny legs were splayed at an odd angle, and his back was still, too still. No breaths moved it up and down. He was never going to enjoy another free spaghetti dinner—or anything else. Jake Lacey was dead.

I pushed up to standing and pulled my phone out of the small bag I always wore when I went outside. My skin turned numb as I jabbed at 911, my shaking finger slipping a couple of times until the call connected.

Jake’s straggly light-brown hair lay in skinny strands wet from the fog. The color of his beat-up old work coat almost matched his hair. I couldn’t see any wounds. No blood stained his coat or marred his skin. I’d never seen a body before, not even an animal except roadkill, and then it was from the window of a car. My mother’s parents had passed away before I was born, my other grandfather had died when I was traveling abroad, and we’d never had pets at home because of my allergies. What happened to Jake? Did he have a heart attack? A drug overdose? Did he even do drugs?

When the dispatcher asked what my emergency was, I said, “There’s a dead person. It’s Jake Lacey.” I managed to keep myself from shrieking again. I was desperate to get home—my house was only a few yards away. I wanted to lock the door and pretend this never happened. But I couldn’t. I was a responsible adult, and a body on the path was out of order. I didn’t like disorderly things.

“What is your location, ma’am?” she asked.

“I’m on the path behind the bike shop.”

“What town, ma’am, and what’s the name of the shop?” The dispatcher’s voice was infinitely patient.

Oh, yeah. The local police used a regional dispatch center. “Sorry. Westham. Mac’s Bikes.” I gave her the address.

“And how do you know this person is dead?”

One of those awful catastrophe giggles threatened to burble up. I swallowed it down. “He’s not breathing and his skin is cold. It hardly even feels like skin.” I turned away from the sight of his body. I had to.

“Do you feel safe?” she asked.

“Yes.” After a beat it occurred to me to add, “Why shouldn’t I?” I gave a quick glance around the fog-shrouded path that looked like a scene in a mystery filmed on the Scottish moors. Shouldn’t I feel safe? Did she mean someone had killed Jake? That was awful. Murder, here?

I’d never felt myself in danger in Westham, not when I was little, not since I’d been back. I knew some of the bigger towns on the Cape were plagued with higher crime rates than we had. Just because the long curving peninsula was a scenic tourist destination didn’t make Cape Cod immune from robbery, addiction, domestic abuse, and other bad things. On the contrary. But they mostly didn’t happen in my town—as far as I knew, anyway. Jake had probably felt safe, too. The thought stabbed me with sadness for him. I shivered, from the shock as well as the cool damp of the night. It had still been warm and sunny when I’d left for the Cozy Capers meeting and I wore only jeans and a Falmouth Road Race t-shirt with my sandals.

“Is anyone with you?” the dispatcher asked, startling me.

I’d forgotten she was on the line. “No.” Nobody living, that is.

“Officers are on their way. Do you feel comfortable staying where you are?”

“I guess.” I’d feel a lot more comfortable once Jake was someone else’s responsibility.

“Please keep this call open until the officers arrive,” she instructed.

“Okay.” I didn’t dare stash the phone for fear I’d press the wrong button, so I stood holding it, like an unfortunate statue. The fog damped all sounds, but a dog barked faintly in the distance, and a big truck downshifted out on the highway a few miles away.

It seemed selfish to feel sorry for myself, but I wished I’d never found Jake. Since I had, I rued not leaving my back porch light on. If someone had killed Jake, they might still be around. My breath grew shallow. I glanced quickly behind me on the trail, but of course I wasn’t able to see a thing through the pea soup. I couldn’t wait for this nightmare to be—

“Mac?” a deep voice called. My boyfriend appeared in the gap in the hedge. “Who are you talking . . . ?” Tim Brunelle’s voice trailed off as he spied Jake. “Is that Jake Lacey? He doesn’t look good.” Tim hurried through the opening in the bushes, made one giant step over Jake’s body, and took my face in both hands. “Are you all right?”

I gazed six inches up into his tanned concerned face. “I’m all right, kind of. But,” I gestured at the ground without really looking, “Jake isn’t.” I could finally hear a siren growing closer. It was about time.

A couple of minutes later the path was transformed. A cruiser had rolled down the trail, barely fitting onto the narrow path, just. The police car now trained spotlights on Jake’s body. Two bag-carting EMTs rushed in from the street—and then stopped rushing. Ambulance lights strobed over the tops of the buildings from the direction of the town’s main drag. A bicycle patrol officer in a uniform polo shirt and black shorts leaned his bike against the hedge, pulled purple gloves out of a back pocket, and squatted next to Jake. Another officer was already stringing yellow plastic POLICE LINE DO NOT CROSS tape over the path behind me.

Tim held my cold hand in his big warm one. He was a tall man with luscious lips, dark blond hair to his shoulders, and well-toned abs, but right now what mattered was the comfort of him standing beside me. Victoria Laitinen, the recently promoted Westham Chief of Police, stood facing Tim and me. Victoria had pulled her white-blond hair back into a neat bun, the way she always wore it, and her petite figure was trim in the navy uniform of the town’s police force.

“You simply happened across Mr. Lacey here,” she said, blinking and setting her lips.

She and I had been high school classmates but not friends, and I remembered that look from twenty years ago. I let out a breath. “Yes. I was walking home from the lighthouse,” I pointed behind me, “and I tripped over Jake. I wasn’t looking down, and the fog was so thick I didn’t see him.”

“You didn’t see anyone else in the vicinity?” Victoria asked. “Hear any noises?”

“Nope. Nobody and nothing.”

“You, Mr. Brunelle?” Victoria turned her all-business gaze on him. “Did you also trip over the body?”

“No, ma’am.” Tim was unfailingly polite and unshakable. “I was supposed to meet Mac at her house. When I got there,” he pointed toward my backyard, “I heard her talking, so I came through the opening in the hedge and found her here.”

“When was that?” Victoria asked.

“I’d just finished talking with the dispatcher,” I offered. “As soon as Tim showed up, I heard the siren. You got here maybe two minutes later.” Westham is such a small town, Victoria almost could have walked here faster.

“When was the last time either of you saw Mr. Lacey alive?”

I gestured for Tim to go first.

He shook his head. “Not in the last couple of days. On Sunday I was doing a training run along the water and I saw Jake with some woman. On the hill down near Westham Point.”

“I saw him at the soup kitchen this afternoon,” I said. “At around five o’clock.”

“The one at the UU church?”

“Yes.” The Unitarian-Universalist church where my father, Joseph Almeida, was minister-in-chief.

“And Mr. Lacey seemed well?” Victoria cocked her head, looking diagonally up at me since I was six inches taller than her.

“Yes.” I thought back to the food line. “He seemed happy about something.”

“What was that something?” She raised eyebrows so pale you could hardly see them.

I cleared my throat. “I’d told him I wouldn’t pay him for the lousy job he did replacing some shingles on my house until he fixed them the right way, but he said that soon he wasn’t going to need my money.”

“Interesting. Sounds like you were angry with him.”

“I wasn’t angry, but I was curious about why he wasn’t going to need what I owed him. Usually he was on my case about paying him promptly. I asked if he’d gotten a full-time job, and he said no, that it was better than a job. That it was ‘wicked good.’ His words.”

She crossed her arms over her chest. “I don’t suppose you got so mad you wanted to harm him, did you?”

“What? That’s crazy! I told you I wasn’t mad at him. I was unhappy about the quality of his work, but . . . wait.” I stared at her. “Do you think someone killed Jake?” I rubbed the moisture off my inch-long curls. “On purpose?” Like what the dispatcher had alluded to when she asked if I felt safe.

She straightened, which really didn’t give her much extra height at all. “Not necessarily. But it was an unattended death, and that makes it a suspicious one. The coroner will determine means of death in due time. My job is to ask the questions.”

“Chief?” the kneeling officer called.

“You both stay right here,” she instructed us before hurrying to his side. She knelt on one knee next to him. “What do you have?”

Tim extended a strong arm around my shoulders as I watched the bike officer turn Jake onto his back. My breath rushed in with a rasping sound and my hand involuntarily covered my mouth. Through the mist-laced light from the spotlights I could see a knife embedded to its hilt in the tender side of Jake’s neck. I’d seen that knife before, with its four-inch carved wooden handle. I’d last seen it embedded in the guts of a striped bass. Held by my brother Derrick.

Tim and I nestled on my two-person sofa an hour later. I’d tucked it in the nook under the sleeping loft. A tall narrow bookcase to our right was jammed three layers deep with cozy mysteries, and a low cabinet to my left held a lamp on top and storage underneath. A small coffee table in front of us also doubled as a bookcase, with a double-sided shelf below the table top. With only four hundred square feet, I had to make every inch count. Usually my cozy home gave me a warm fuzzy feeling inside. Not tonight.

“Cheers.” He held up the glass of cabernet sauvignon he’d brought. “Even though it’s not a cheery night.”

I clinked and sipped before speaking. “No, it’s not.” The fog still filled the air outside and I was glad for the electric heater on the wall even though it was June. “Not cheery at all, in more ways than one.” Victoria had kept us at the crime scene for another half hour, so it was already past nine thirty. She’d said a detective would want to talk to me tomorrow.

Belle, my African Gray parrot, hopped onto Tim’s shoulder. “Gimme a kiss, handsome.” She cocked her head, making a kissing sound. “Gimme a kiss, huh?”

Tim almost spilled his wine, he laughed so hard. “Did you teach her that?”

I giggled. “No, but I’ve said it to you before.” Belle, the only pet I wasn’t allergic to, had been with me since I moved back to Westham a year ago. I’d gotten her when I’d graduated from college. These birds lived for decades, and my parents had kept her during my years abroad. “Go on, she won’t stop until you at least make the sound back.”

Tim rolled his eyes but blew Belle a kiss.

“Mmm.” The parrot nodded her head. “How about a treat? Gimme a peanut please.”

“Belle,” I scolded. “No treats before bed. Go get in your cage.”

She gave me a wolf whistle but obeyed, hopping to the bookcase and then to her cage. In a compact space like this, she didn’t have far to go.

“Oh, well.” I swirled the wine in the glass, watching the red trail down the sides. But that reminded me too much of blood. When I shuddered, Tim squeezed my shoulder.

“Thinking about Jake?”

“Of course.” I set the glass down and twisted to face him, wrapping my arms around my knees. “You saw the knife. That means he was murdered. Do you know of anybody who had it in for him? Except, I can’t believe someone would go so far as to actually kill another person. Right here in Westham.”

“Murders happen all the time. You read books about them every week.”

“But those are fiction! They’re made up. I read stories that come out of an author’s imagination, Tim. They’re not real life.”

“Ever hear of the news?” He kept his voice gentle. “Dorchester, Chicago, LA, Miami. And it’s not only big cities. Even in little towns people are murdered.” He sipped from his own glass.

“I guess. Jake said he was going to be coming into some money soon. I wonder where he thought it was coming from.”

“My first thought was blackmail.”

My eyes went wide. “Blackmail? Like he knew dirt on somebody and was going to make them pay for not telling?”

Tim bobbed his head up and down once.

“Doesn’t that happen only in books, too?”

“No. I read about a guy doing exactly that just last year. Got caught, finally. I guess he was lucky he didn’t get killed for doing it.”

I grimaced.

“So did I detect some tension between you and the police chief?” He nudged my foot with his knee.

I rolled my eyes. “Yeah. She never did like me. She thought we were rivals in high school.”

“Were you?”

“We both got top grades. She was the top competitor on debate team. I was president of the Math Club. I didn’t care, but she always had a thing about me.” I lifted a shoulder and dropped it. “It was ages ago. I still don’t care. As long as she doesn’t accuse me of murder based on some imagined slight from decades past.”

“She can’t do that. They need evidence to make an arrest. They don’t have any.”

“I guess.” I frowned. Should I tell him I thought the knife was Derrick’s? Maybe it was a common haft. Maybe dozens of people on the Cape used them to gut fish. Just because I’d never seen one like that other than my brother’s didn’t mean his was the only one. I was going to keep that bit to myself for now.

Tim stroked my foot. “I bet you were cute in high school.”

I’d met the hunk. . .