Kappy King and the Pie Kaper

Book 3: Amish Mystery

by Amy Lillard

Genres: Amish & Mennonite; Culinary Cozy Mysteries

Synopsis

Kathryn "Kappy" Kings skill at making kapps for the Amish women of Blue Sky, Pennsylvania, are unparalleled. But she's also dangerously good at discovering dark truths beneath this peaceful valley . . .

When an accident puts beloved bishop's wife Alma Ebersol in a coma, many in Blue Sky are quick to blame struggling widow Frannie Lehman. Both women are the best bakers around, but for years Alma's boysenberry pies have been more award-winning—and profitable—than Frannie's. And with Alma out of this falls county festival, Frannie's pie finally wins first prize. But when Alma dies and Frannie's children fall victim to gossip and bullying, Kappy is determined to uncover the real truth.

Soon Kappy and her outcast friend Edie have their hands full of odd clues. What do Alma's strange last words mean? Why would someone break into her house just to steal a quilt? Who is the mysterious new piemaker in town—and why is she still in Blue Sky after losing the festival competition? When long-buried family secrets and contested legacies start getting into the mix, Kappy and Edie must work fast before another victim gets a deadly pie in the face . . .

Release date: December 18, 2018

Publisher: Zebra Books

Print pages: 352

Sample

“Did you hear?” Edie Peachey shut her car door, then opened it again to shut off the engine. She pushed the door closed and started toward the porch where Kappy waited.

Kathryn King, known to most in her small Amish community in Blue Sky, Pennsylvania, as Kappy, propped her hands onto her hips and eyed her friend. “Hi, Edie. So good to see you, too. Yes, the weather has been nice lately, but September always is, don’t you think?”

Edie ignored her sarcasm and plowed ahead. “Alma Miller fell out of her cherry tree and is in a coma.”

It could have been the last thing Kappy expected her to say, but something seemed off. Edie was about the best friend Kappy had ever had. The murder of Edie’s mother had pulled them together and bonded them in a strong way. The pair had left no stone unturned as they tried to clear Edie’s brother of the charges. Yet despite Edie’s conservative upbringing—she had been raised Amish, then left to live among the English—she had the tendency to be a bit dramatic in both action and appearance. Like today’s outfit of black-and-white-checkered pants and a bright red shirt made out of stretchy material that clung to her in a way that made Kappy a bit uncomfortable. She supposed Edie didn’t dress any more risqué than the other English women Kappy encountered. At least her clothes matched today, though the top clashed with Edie’s swirly cotton-candy-colored hair.

“Did you put blue in your hair?” She had dyed it pink a couple of months back and it had taken this long for Kappy to get used to it. Now this!

“Just a bit. Did you hear what I said?”

“I did.” But still the words seemed impossible. “Where did you hear such a thing?”

Edie hooked one finger back over her shoulder toward the main road. “I was at the Super Saver, and I heard Mary Ann Peachey and Bertha Troyer talking about it.”

“You haven’t been back a year and already you are falling victim to idle gossip.”

Edie cocked her head to one side. “I never said Mary Raber was involved.”

“Like it matters.”

Everyone knew that Mary Raber was the biggest gossip in the village of Blue Sky, but that didn’t mean there weren’t amateurs out there jockeying for her title.

Jockeying. That was her word for the day in her word-a-day calendar. And she thought she would never have the opportunity to use that one. Just goes to show. Kappy loved her calendar. The Amish might only attend school until the eighth grade, but one should never stop learning. At least that’s what she thought.

“Coma,” Edie said again slowly. “I think you missed that important detail the first go around.”

“I heard it.” Kappy took a step back to let Edie into the house, then she whistled for Elmer. The pup stopped sniffing at a particularly interesting blade of grass at the edge of the drive. He raised his snout into the air, back leg raised and tail out in the perfect beagle “point.” “Come on,” she called.

Elmer raced toward her, ears floating on the breeze as he ran. He was getting big, losing his puppy coat and changing colors the way beagles were prone to do. White paws had gained freckles of brown. His ears, once dark silky black, were now a rusty velvet brown. Even the white strip down the center of his face seemed to have shifted. But inside he was all mischievous puppy.

“And you’re not concerned for our friend?” Edie continued after Kappy had shut the door behind them.

Elmer raced to the kitchen to get a drink of water, then collapsed in front of the hearth to chew on a rawhide bone. He held it between his front paws as he gnawed on it from the side. Kappy had learned the hard way: It was get him something to chew on or keep buying new shoes.

“I’m considering the source.” There was no proof anywhere that any of this were true, but as usual, Edie had fallen into her typical drama-filled response. “And the Millers don’t have a cherry tree.”

Edie waved a hand around as if erasing Kappy’s logic. “Details, details.”

But if that information was incorrect, then what else was?

“Besides, I think the preacher’s wife and the deacon’s wife would know.”

Kappy stopped. Neither woman was prone to gossip, but it had been a slow fall. Well, things had slowed down after Sally June Esh was run off the road, but this was another matter altogether. “They don’t have a cherry tree.”

Edie shrugged. “So she fell out of some other kind of tree. Coma,” she repeated, even slower this time.

The last thing Kappy wanted to do was jump to conclusions, but her heart sank despite her resolve. Alma Miller . . . in the hospital? In a coma? “Maybe we should go check it out. When did this happen?”

“Yesterday,” Edie said with a nod. “Maybe the day before.”

Two days? Where had she been that she was just now hearing about this? Kappy didn’t have an answer for that. She had been right where she was now, but she had always been a little on the outside of her community. Sometimes she heard news right after it happened and sometimes she would only find out about it at their every-other-week church services.

“So . . . ?” Edie asked.

Kappy jerked herself out of her thoughts and eyed her friend. She and Edie were a mismatched pair to be certain, but ever since she had returned to Blue Sky, Edie had become more than just a friend. She was Kappy’s best friend. Something Kappy hadn’t had in a long time. Kappy swallowed hard and nodded. “Jah. Let’s go to the hospital and see what we can find out.”

“I’ll drive,” Edie said.

Once again Kappy nodded and a worried frown puckered Edie’s brow. “You aren’t even going to argue about it?”

“Not today.” It was a standing disagreement between the two of them. Since Edie had left the church, she drove around in a fancy English car. Well, Kappy supposed it wasn’t all that fancy as far as cars went, but it was fancy to her nonetheless.

“Are you sure you’re feeling all right?” Edie took a step toward her and pressed the back of one hand to Kappy’s forehead, as if to check for fever. “You don’t feel warm.”

Kappy smacked her hand away. “I’m fine. I would just like to . . .” She would just like to what? Know as soon as possible. There had been too many tragedies in Blue Sky lately and if this one happened not to be true, she wanted to know as soon as humanly possible. “Go,” she finally said.

Edie tossed her hair out of her face and nodded. “I have to take Jimmy to work in a bit. I’ll get him, then swing back by and we’ll go over to the hospital, ’kay?”

“Sure.”

Edie shot her one last concerned look and headed out the front door.

Kappy stood where she was for a moment, a silent prayer for Alma running through her mind. How she hoped that Alma had no need, but two days with the same rumor floating around meant one thing: There was some truth in it after all. But how much?

She supposed she would find out soon enough. Or she would find out when they got to the hospital that someone was making things up. As much as she hated a wasted trip, she kind of hoped that would happen. She hated the thought of something bad happening to Alma. She was as sweet as they came. Though if Kappy was being perfectly honest, Alma was a bit prideful over her pies.

She sighed. Once again human nature won out over the church.

Elmer abandoned his chew toy and ran toward the door, stopping short and sniffing the air before plopping his rear down and howling. She didn’t think Edie would be back yet, but she never really knew with her friend. And though Kappy was constantly reminding people that she didn’t do business from her front porch, inevitably someone came around and knocked.

“Around back,” she called. “Down the basement.”

“I don’t need a prayer kapp. I just want to talk to you,” the male voice returned. And it wasn’t Edie’s brother Jimmy Peachey.

“Jack Jones,” she said.

“The one and only,” he said. At least that’s what she thought he said. It was hard to hear with all the noise her dog was making.

“Hush,” she told Elmer and stepped over him to the door. Except Elmer picked that time to move and Kappy ended up thumping hard against wall. “Crazy dog,” she muttered, then wrenched open the door.

As expected, Jack Jones stood on the porch. Jack was tall and swarthy (last month’s word), the image of a pirate, if they still existed like in the old days. His eyes were so dark she could barely see their pupils. The hair on his head was the color of a raven’s wing and that on his face was black as well. Not that he had a beard. It just seemed that no matter when she saw him he always had stubble, like his facial hair resented being shaved off and grew back almost immediately. “Everything okay?” he asked.

“Jah. Sure.” Kappy ran her hands down her front, smoothing out her apron.

“I thought I heard something.”

She shook her head. “Just graceful me tripping over this terrible dog.” The smile on her face and the affection in her voice took all the sting from her words. “What brings you out this way, Detective?”

He hesitated and for the first time since Kappy had met him, Jack looked . . . uncertain. “Is Edie here?” he asked.

She shook her head.

He looked almost relieved. “Can I talk to you about something? Inside?”

She stepped back so Jack could enter. “Of course.” But she couldn’t stop the small frown of concern that wrinkled her brow. Jack uncertain was one thing but needing to talk to her privately was another matter altogether.

Jack moved past her and into her living room. He shifted from one foot to the other, that cop confidence momentarily put on hold.

“What do you want to talk about?” Kappy asked. All this shifting was making her nervous.

“I suppose you heard about Alma Miller.”

She nodded and motioned for him to take a seat on the couch while she settled down in her favorite rocking chair. “Edie said something about it earlier. That she fell out of her cherry tree and was in a coma.”

“She had some head trauma and is in a coma, yes,” Jack said.

Which was not exactly falling from a possibly nonexistent cherry tree. “So she didn’t fall out of a tree? I told Edie the Millers didn’t have a cherry tree. Now a crab apple tree . . .”

That was one thing she knew was on their property. Alma Miller was famous in the valley for her crab apple pie recipe. Well, all her pies really. Every year she took first place at the fall festival with her mouthwatering efforts. She claimed fresh ingredients were the secret, but Kappy had a feeling there was more to it than that.

“I can’t discuss the particulars of her case with you, but I do need to ask you a question.”

“Okay,” Kappy stammered. She’d had her doubts about the seriousness or even the validity of Alma’s accident, but this just proved it.

Validity. That was another one from her calendar. Kappy loved her word-a-day calendar, but validity was one she never thought she would get to put into practice.

Jack pulled an envelope from inside his jacket and shook something out. After a moment Kappy realized they were photographs.

She shook her head. “I don’t want—” She didn’t finish that thought. She had no desire to look at the images if they were of what she thought they were. She didn’t need to see Alma bent and broken on the ground outside her house. It was simply too much.

Jack ignored her protests and started to lay the pictures out on the coffee table where she could clearly see them. She didn’t want to look, but she didn’t seem to be able to help herself. But they weren’t of poor Alma laying under a cherry-possibly-crab-apple tree. They were of the inside of the house.

Kappy relaxed a bit and let her eyes take in the images before her. The pictures all showed the same thing. It took her a minute to determine exactly what she was looking at. It was the floor of Alma’s kitchen. The worn yellow linoleum was covered with flour, as if it had been spilled by a child who then ran through the mess, scattering it about. The pictures may have been of the same subject, but they had been taken from every angle imaginable. In one, she could see the old-fashioned tin cannister that Alma kept her flour in. She brought it to every pie competition every year and Kappy recognized it from that. In another, she could just make out the legs of the kitchen table along with a couple of the chairs. But each seemed to focus on the spread of flour.

“She fell in her house?” Kappy asked. All the rumors had indicated she had been outside. But if this was an accident, then why was the police involved?

“Can you make out these words?”

Kappy squinted at one of the pictures on the top of the pile. “Did someone draw in the flour?” she hesitantly asked. The thought was ridiculous, but she asked regardless.

Jack cleared his throat. “Something like that.” He shifted in his seat and Kappy realized that his lack of confidence could be contributed to concern over how much he should say to her.

She turned her gaze from the photographs to Jack. “Why are you telling me all this?”

“There were words, symbols maybe, drawn in the spilled flour.”

Kappy gasped. “You think she was attacked and her attacker left a message in the flour?” The thought almost had her jumping to her feet. Somehow she contained her surprise.

“I might have expected this from Edie,” Jack grumbled.

“Is that a no?”

“It’s a no.” Jack pinched the bridge of his nose as if he was starting to get a headache. “We believe that Alma wrote a message in the flour before she lost consciousness.”

Kappy nodded. “That makes more sense. Jah.” She blamed Edie. She was always running around coming up with crazy ideas about this, that, and the other, but Kappy could forgive her. Edie was merely bored in their quiet village after so many years living among the English.

“Is Alma going to be okay?” she asked.

Jack gave a small shrug. “We don’t know. And this may be the only clue we have to finding out who did this.”

“So she was attacked.” The thought sent shivers all through her. It was hard enough to think of the bishop’s poor wife falling from her favorite fruit tree, but taken down in her own house . . .

“I didn’t say that.”

He didn’t have to. If this were nothing more than a simple accident, like tripping over the cat, then Jack Jones would be off talking to someone else about another crime in the village. Instead, he was here . . .

“What are the clues?” Kappy finally asked.

“You know I can’t—”

“Discuss the particulars of the case. Jah, I know. But was it a B&E?” She wasn’t sure where she had picked up the term, but she was self-satisfied that she had found an opportunity to use it in conversation.

He seemed reluctant, then went ahead and answered. “Nothing seems to be missing. There were no signs of forced entry.”

“Of course not,” Kappy said. “Bishop Sam never locked his doors.”

“Never?”

“He said it was a sign of lack of faith.”

Jack’s forehead puckered into a small frown. “What does lack of faith have to do with it?”

“It’s all part of trusting God and accepting His will.”

Jack seemed to think this over for a moment. “I guess.” He didn’t sound convinced.

“Preacher Sam used to always tell him, ‘Do not put thy Lord God to the test.’” A small smile pulled at her lips. The two had been at odds over the matter as long as she could remember.

“Who else knows that they don’t lock their doors?”

Kappy raised one shoulder in a half shrug. “Everyone, I guess. I mean, it’s never been a secret or anything.”

“Well, that doesn’t help much.”

Kappy glanced back down at the photographs still spread across her coffee table. “Why are you showing these to me?” she finally asked. It was the one question about the entire exchange that had her confused.

“We’re having trouble figuring out what the words mean. I thought perhaps they could be Pennsylvania Dutch.”

She picked up one of the images and studied it. She hadn’t noticed it before, but there, in the mounds of powdery white flour, she could just make out a word. She carefully placed it back and picked up the next photograph.

“Is it?”

“Is it what?” Kappy asked. She was so intent on studying the picture that she lost the thread of the conversation.

“Dutch.” A small note of irritation colored his voice.

“You know Edie speaks Dutch as well.”

He nodded. “I know.”

But he didn’t want to ask her. That much was obvious.

Kappy waited, hoping that if she stalled long enough Jack would crack and tell her exactly why he didn’t want to tell Edie.

“Well?” he asked.

“Why didn’t you take these to Edie to interpret?” she finally asked outright.

“Really?”

As far as answers went, it wasn’t exactly what she had hoped.

They sat in silence for a full moment before Jack finally spoke.

“Can you read it or not? I mean, we thought it was Pennsylvania Dutch, but it could be another language.”

“It is,” Kappy said. “It’s English.”

Jack blinked at her as if the movement of his lids would bring all the wayward pieces back into focus. “What?”

“It’s English.” She tapped the photograph with her index finger. “Alma has always had the worst penmanship.” She stopped, shook her head. “Do you still call it penmanship if she wrote it with her finger? She did write it with her finger, right?”

Jack didn’t answer, just tugged the photo from her grasp and studied it. “This is English?” he asked. She was sure to clarify one last time.

“Without a doubt.”

“Is that a nine?” he asked.

Kappy peered to where he pointed to a spot on one of the pictures. “Looks like it to me.”

“And this says . . .” He hesitated as he tried to make out the letters. “Babies?”

“That’s what I see.”

Jack frowned. “Nine babies? What does that mean?”

Kappy opened her mouth to respond, but he waved her words away before she could even say them. “Rhetorical.”

And because of her word-a-day calendar she knew exactly what that meant.

“And I think the other words are ME and blue.”

He shook his head and mumbled something that sounded a lot like “that doesn’t mak. . .